3 ms·
People one or two generations before you felt that about the cold war.
by inigyou 5mo ago
People one or two generations before you felt that about the cold war.
- TheOtherHobbes 5mo agoThe cold war never heated up. Even if we stopped using fossil fuels tomorrow, it will take millennia for the climate to return to normal.
- xienze 5mo agoWon't the climate change naturally even in the absence of fossil fuels? Like it has during all of history? What's "normal" is based on a small slice of human history, which itself is a small slice of the planet's history.
- DFHippie 5mo agoIt isn't the fact of change but the rate of change which is anomalous.
- sfn42 5mo agoYour question betrays the fact that you simply don't understand the scale of what's happening. Imagine a line chart. It displays average global temperature over millions of years. It goes up a little, it goes down a little, it fluctuates over time. That's the natural change. It occurs over thousands and millions of years. Looking at the last few decades on that chart, you'll see a wall. It's going almost straight up compared to the rest that just meanders lazily. You can see a few other similar peaks on the chart many millions of years in the past, they generally correspond with things like apocalyptic meteorite impacts etc. And even then the change occurs much more slowly than what we're seeing now. It's honestly insane to me that we're watching the world end and half of people are like "but are we sure this isn't normal?" Yes we're sure. We double checked. Just look at any "global average temperature" chart and try to predict where it's going. This isn't the stock market it won't just randomly start doing something else. The movement we're seeing is directly correlated to our ghg emissions, and there's a lag - the effects of current emissions won't be fully seen until up to two decades from now. So even if we stopped right now it would continue warming for decades. Warming also releases more GHGs. As poles and permafrost thaws, enormous amounts of methane are released that was previously trapped, further accelerating warming and acting as a positive feedback loop on top of our steadily rising emissions. In short were fucked, we know it, and anyone who doesn't know is not paying attention.
- tasuki 5mo ago> it will take millennia for the climate to return to normal No. There is no such thing as "normal" climate. It's ever changing. We're just making the change a whole lot faster.
- simmerup 4mo agoReplace 'normal' with 'optimal for humanity' then., I'm sure the lizards will love the new normal though.
- gitaarik 5mo agoWhat's "normal" really? You could argue the climate has never actually been normal, or it always has been and always will
- notrealyme123 5mo agoI think thats the wrong level of abstraction. The cold war ended, but clima change will not end.
- iso1631 5mo agoNuclear winter may cancel it out.
- underdeserver 5mo agoIt can change, if we get to net negative emissions. Not probable but possible.
- phreeza 5mo agoOr solar geoengineering? Which is scary but becoming more likely it seems.
- adrianN 5mo agoIt will just take at least three or four generations to get back to 90's climate, provided we don't trigger any irreversible tipping points, like the melting of the permafrost, in which case the climate is messed up for millennia.
- blooalien 5mo agoThe melting of the permafrost is already underway and it's not looking good for any hope of it slowing down, and that's only one (of many) irreversible tipping point we're facing right now. But hey, it'll be fine because it's all just "fake news" anyhow. (I wish that were actually true about it not being real, but it's crystal clear to anyone with an IQ higher than a houseplant that the scientists were right all along and we really should have started acting on all this stuff decades ago.) :(
- epgui 5mo agoThe word abstraction does not mean the same thing as the words analogy or comparison.
- freetonik 5mo agoWell, they had a point, and we've got pretty close to that outcome. It didn't happen, thus today we're able to discuss the fact that it didn't happen.
- IneffablePigeon 5mo agoThe conditions leading to the Cold War were reversible, this crisis is becoming very much less so. Despite what the carbon capture techno optimists say.
- joe_mamba 5mo ago>The conditions leading to the Cold War were reversible, this crisis is becoming very much less so. During the covid start lockdowns when everyone was forced to WFH and nobody was driving to work for a couple of weeks, we saw a massive decrease in CO2 and emissions. So it can be reversed, we just don't want to because we gotta keep the GDP hamster wheel moving
- rsynnott 5mo agoWe did not see a massive decrease. We saw a short-lived drop to levels normal in the mid tens. It is barely a blip on the graph. WFH won’t save us, unfortunately.
- joe_mamba 5mo agoMy bad, I was only talking about the readings in my city, not the whole planet. I assumed it would scale to the whole planet in that period.
- rsynnott 5mo agoAh. I’d consider _city-level_ readings an absolutely useless metric here, because, particularly if it’s a city with a large commuter hinterland, a lot of people were simply not present in the city, but still existed out there somewhere, running their heating/cooling/etc. Daytime populations of large cities generally dropped during the covid wfh period, so yeah, no shit CO2 emissions dropped; people were off emitting CO2 elsewhere.
- sfn42 5mo agoIf you actually look at the numbers of carbon capture its entirely obvious that it can't work. It's honestly strange to me that they even waste money on it, personally I think it's a distraction - "look we're working on a fix, now let us just pump up the rest of this oil in the mean time and we'll definitely fix it later". In order to just offset our current emissions, we would need around a million carbon capture facilities equivalent to the largest one we currently have. For comparison, the number of power plants in the entire world is a few tens of thousands. So we'd need maybe like 50 times as many capture plants as we currently have power plants. Like it's not even in the neighbourhood of realistic, it's just completely infeasible and I am sure engineers know that. You basically need to suck the whole atmosphere through facilities, and there's a lot of atmosphere.
- iso1631 5mo agoThere's a lot of worry about the future, and has been since world-ending threats became apparent However while apocalypse scenarios (Nuclear war, asteroid impact, AI powered biological warfare) are low likelihood, extreme impact, climate change is extreme likelihood and high impact, not just the immediate effect on places like Europe, Canada etc, but also from the conflicts that climate change will drive, which in turn may escalate to those extreme impact nuclear wars. On a 5x5 matrix, grand extinction events would be a 5 for effect but a 1 for likelihood, putting them in a "medium-high" category Climate change is a 3-4 on effect but a 4-5 o likelihood, putting them in a "very-high" risk category
- graemep 5mo agoSpace weather that would bring down our systems is not such low likelihood. I am not convinced nuclear war or biological warfare are as unlikely as you think. We have historically had narrow escapes from nuclear war.
- hyperbovine 5mo agoClimate change also greatly increases the chance of a huge global conflict breaking out.
- graemep 5mo agoIt might raise the chance of some conflicts (e.g. over Antarctica or Russia's border) and some land grabs, but I cannot see it leading to a world war.
- swiftcoder 5mo agoThat largely depends on to what degree food production collapses in newly-tropical regions. A whole bunch of staple agricultural production isn't going to survive widespread drought and heatwaves, and everyone dependent on those food sources is going to end up very hungry, and taking a hard look at cooler neighbouring regions...
- 5mo ago