3 ms·
Revenues aren't profits. Over the last 4 years their pre-tax profit on revenues was 3.6%. Even assuming this was much more lucrative than average, I suspect the
by wpietri 14y ago
Revenues aren't profits. Over the last 4 years their pre-tax profit on revenues was 3.6%. Even assuming this was much more lucrative than average, I suspect they lost money.
The real cost doesn't come in the suit, though. It comes in lost opportunities and increased deal-making costs because potential partners are much less likely to trust them now.
- icambron 14y agoI agree. Also, the 140 that BB would have made wouldn't have all gone to Techforward anyway, whether it was profit or not. What we'd really have to compare is the 22 million + fees to how much they would have paid Techforward as part of the partnership. Since there are a lot of other costs to a buyback program (e.g. actually buying things back from customers), 22 doesn't sound unreasonable. This was a huge, shortsighted waste on BB's part.
- unreal37 14y agoThis program, the buyback program they got sued over, was almost all "pure profit". Kinda like the extended warranty they try to sell you. It's 300% profit margin business. The court documents talk about it Best Buy expecting it to be a cash machine and driving instant profits to the Best Buy bottom line, and that TechForward would have made about $20MM per year just from the licensing deal. Best Buy still made "tons of cash" from this. The punitive damages of only $5MM are a shame. This was wilful theft of IP.