3 ms·

I admire your efforts here, but you’re tilting against windmills with your comments here. There’s a loud contingent of AI skeptics on HN who haven’t updated th

I admire your efforts here, but you’re tilting against windmills with your comments here. There’s a loud contingent of AI skeptics on HN who haven’t updated their tired arguments in years. Their fervent hatred of AI is mere religious dogma at this point, not anything empirical. The upside is that we’re competing against these folks. Let them continue to stick their heads in the sand.

heresalexandria 4mo ago
For sure, I appreciate your comment - this is a tough crowd, but it's their loss.
comfysocks 4mo ago
Somewhere, someone may be painting an equally reductive picture of you and your position. You two are obviously smart people, but have you considered that maybe you are unconsciously being backed into a position that is just as absolutist as those you are arguing against? That you are just taking the opposite side in a binary argument where each side sees only one side of the coin?
- senordevnyc 4mo ago
  I use these tools all day every day, and the feeble arguments against them that I’m referencing don’t match my experience from a year ago, let alone today. I rarely argue much about AI on HN anymore, it seems utterly pointless. It’s genuinely sad to me to see how many here are so blinded by rage and fear that they can’t have an honest conversation about the pros and cons of AI. Obviously not everyone, but that’s who my comment was addressing. I also wouldn’t characterize my position as absolutist or one side of a binary. Interesting that you’d assume that.
  - comfysocks 4mo ago
    Fair enough. I too use LLM coding tools all day everyday. If we’re specifically talking about the arguments in this thread, I have experienced both sides of the argument. Some use cases are more in-distribution than others. I wouldn’t dismiss either side out of hand. I see it more as a “yes, but…”
    - senordevnyc 4mo ago
      I’m talking about this kind of inane bullshit: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48775974 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48775974 Or even worse: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48775860 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48775860
      - AlexeyBelov 4mo ago
        But you _are_ building a SaaS according to your bio.

heresalexandria 4mo ago

For sure, I appreciate your comment - this is a tough crowd, but it's their loss.

comfysocks 4mo ago

Somewhere, someone may be painting an equally reductive picture of you and your position. You two are obviously smart people, but have you considered that maybe you are unconsciously being backed into a position that is just as absolutist as those you are arguing against? That you are just taking the opposite side in a binary argument where each side sees only one side of the coin?

senordevnyc 4mo ago
I use these tools all day every day, and the feeble arguments against them that I’m referencing don’t match my experience from a year ago, let alone today. I rarely argue much about AI on HN anymore, it seems utterly pointless. It’s genuinely sad to me to see how many here are so blinded by rage and fear that they can’t have an honest conversation about the pros and cons of AI. Obviously not everyone, but that’s who my comment was addressing. I also wouldn’t characterize my position as absolutist or one side of a binary. Interesting that you’d assume that.
- comfysocks 4mo ago
  Fair enough. I too use LLM coding tools all day everyday. If we’re specifically talking about the arguments in this thread, I have experienced both sides of the argument. Some use cases are more in-distribution than others. I wouldn’t dismiss either side out of hand. I see it more as a “yes, but…”
  - senordevnyc 4mo ago
    I’m talking about this kind of inane bullshit: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48775974 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48775974 Or even worse: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48775860 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48775860
    - AlexeyBelov 4mo ago
      But you _are_ building a SaaS according to your bio.