3 ms·
I stated it in another comment, but the mobile-first strategy is more about user interaction design than implementation technology choices. I tend to agree, bu
by Silhouette 14y ago
I stated it in another comment, but the mobile-first strategy is more about user interaction design than implementation technology choices.
I tend to agree, but for this discussion I'm trying to restrict my use of the term to the distinction in the original articles, which as I read them is very much about the technology platform choice rather than matters of presentation or user experience. (Perhaps I've misunderstood the author's intent and that is why I so strongly disagreed with the argument from the earlier blog post.)
If you start a new startup today and you have resources to design a single user experience, it's a choice of designing for mobile/tablets or for laptops. Responsive design is not a solution here, as you have to think full user flows.
With due respect, I don't accept your premise. We're doing it right now, with a web app that uses similar tricks to responsive design to present things differently on different devices. With the obvious exception of collecting payments, where a native mobile app probably has at least one major option that a web app doesn't, we aim for a very similar user flow regardless of the device used to access our service.
This particular app is more about consumption than interaction, so of course we're not representative of the entire field and YMMV. However, I'd say the main thing that lets us present a user experience that is similar across devices is just keeping the whole model very simple and designing the interactions/controls carefully so they are viable on both large and small screens. We do occasionally adapt a certain part of the UI to present things in a more natural way depending on the device, but we don't find this is a problem very often in practice. We've been considering various more interactive/social features, and I would agree that these require more adaptation to suit different devices, but even so, I don't see us building two fundamentally different user interfaces any time soon. Until evidence shows me otherwise, if your user flows are simple and your underlying data/presentation models are good, I don't see why a single user experience with localised enhancements/adaptations can't serve many kinds of device well.
- dirtyaura 14y agoI agree that with apps that are mostly consumption, responsive design can go a long way. However, I think the biggest wins in the future will be for products that somehow crack the problem of easy manipulation for different application domains in mobile. (We are working on that, rethinking what spreadsheets are in the touch device era)