3 ms·

I for one would NOT use this service. There is a lot of mistrust in this industry, and no one wants to potentially give away an idea for the sake of third party

by gyazbek 14y ago

I for one would NOT use this service. There is a lot of mistrust in this industry, and no one wants to potentially give away an idea for the sake of third party market analysis that isn't that well known or confidential.

vlokshin 14y ago
Point taken, and we do appreciate the feedback. The same can be said for KickStarter/Indiegogog/Everyone else. We're trying to build the same model, but hoping (and assuming) that people are quicker to give their interest, and sign up as an early adopter for an idea if its built, than to open up their wallets to new ideas. As far as giving away their idea, we're definitely going to try to do what we can to protect those posting from a legal side, or at least offer a VERY convenient way to say "hey! this was mine on this day"
- tmh88j 14y ago
  > KickStarter/Indiegogog/Everyone else. Don't you generally have to show something off (as in hey, look what I'm in the process of, care to join?) with those to get backing? This is just pitching an idea, right?
- phatbyte 14y ago
  What kind of legal side can you guarantee to anyone ? Would this work overseas ? Also, ideas are just ideas until someone actually creates it. Not to piss on your parade, but you can't protect anything.
- danso 14y ago
  With Kickstarter, though, the "upvoters" get actual returns from their votes (the "vote" being money and "returns" being gifts)
atte 14y ago
You wouldn't want to post up something like a "trade secret" on our site, that's for sure. However, living in Silicon Valley I have actually found that most people in the tech community don't have problems sharing their ideas. I like to share my ideas as often as possible, because it helps me evaluate which ones are the best, and often people offer meaningful suggestions. At the end of the day, success comes down to execution, but it's nice to have some confidence that you aren't starting down a path on false premises.

by gyazbek 14y ago

vlokshin 14y ago

Point taken, and we do appreciate the feedback. The same can be said for KickStarter/Indiegogog/Everyone else. We're trying to build the same model, but hoping (and assuming) that people are quicker to give their interest, and sign up as an early adopter for an idea if its built, than to open up their wallets to new ideas. As far as giving away their idea, we're definitely going to try to do what we can to protect those posting from a legal side, or at least offer a VERY convenient way to say "hey! this was mine on this day"

tmh88j 14y ago
> KickStarter/Indiegogog/Everyone else. Don't you generally have to show something off (as in hey, look what I'm in the process of, care to join?) with those to get backing? This is just pitching an idea, right?
phatbyte 14y ago
What kind of legal side can you guarantee to anyone ? Would this work overseas ? Also, ideas are just ideas until someone actually creates it. Not to piss on your parade, but you can't protect anything.
danso 14y ago
With Kickstarter, though, the "upvoters" get actual returns from their votes (the "vote" being money and "returns" being gifts)

atte 14y ago

You wouldn't want to post up something like a "trade secret" on our site, that's for sure. However, living in Silicon Valley I have actually found that most people in the tech community don't have problems sharing their ideas. I like to share my ideas as often as possible, because it helps me evaluate which ones are the best, and often people offer meaningful suggestions. At the end of the day, success comes down to execution, but it's nice to have some confidence that you aren't starting down a path on false premises.