4 ms·
>no need to learn, just ask it to do it for you And that's how skills die.
by coldtea 4mo ago
>no need to learn, just ask it to do it for you
And that's how skills die.
- CamperBob2 4mo agoWhen's the last time you shoed a horse? The reason I delegate so much of local LLM installation and administration to Claude Code is simply because there's no point learning practical things that will work completely differently in a couple of years, or in memorizing procedures that I'll forget long before I need to perform them again. No longer having to sweat all the details is a Good Thing, not a Bad Thing.
- coldtea 4mo ago>When's the last time you shoed a horse? That skill died too, so what's your point?
- CamperBob2 4mo agoSkills sometimes do that. What's your point?
- coldtea 4mo agoSkills are good. They shouldn't do that.
- a96 4mo agoIt did not. There are professional horse shoers like there always were. Not in huge numbers, but there are. Domesticated horses didn't just disappear from the world.
- dofm 4mo agoI am not sure I disagree, and I certainly don't mean to disagree very fervently. But I think if you want to really learn to ride well, understand horses well, there might be some benefit in learning how to shoe a horse. At some level it should never only be someone else's job.
- verdverm 4mo agoAt the same time, most people can drive without understanding how a car works.
- saganus 4mo agoYou actually do need some understanding of how a car works, no? For example, you need to know it uses gasoline (or diesel), it requires oil changes every certain amount of time, break pad replacement, etc. You also probably need to know that you can't operate cars over a certain amount of water, that you need a driver's license, stopping at red lights, etc. Sure, you might not need to be a mechanic, but that's far from not understanding how a car works, which to me sounds similar to knowing how to shoe a horse, which is different than being a horse vet.
- coldtea 4mo agoYes, and they're all the worse, more at the mercy of car companies and mechanics, and less aware of the world they live and operate in, for it...
- psychoslave 4mo agoHaving to shoe a horse never was a general skill. Maybe a more apt analogy would be a skill like making fire without a lighter.
- sanderjd 4mo agoWriting software never was never a general skill either though? Or am I misunderstanding your point?
- psychoslave 4mo agoYes, LLM are thrown through pretty much everyone digital life whether they like it or not, it's not just devs. It might even unlock exploring things that need code that average user wouldn't have dared to do before.
- WickyNilliams 4mo agoIf I worked with horses for 8 hours a day I imagine the answer would be "recently"
- charcircuit 4mo agoExcept with AI models it's possible to make a backup of them creating a permanent artifact of a skill.
- ddalex 4mo agoAnd why is this skill important, if a machine can do it ? What's the last time you ploughed your field with oxen ?
- a96 4mo agoThe skill isn't the plowing. The skill is thinking and learning and the ability that atrophies is that of mental effort (which is what drives thinking and learning). Losing those will affect people's lives and potentially even their humanity.