3 ms·
> Also, I'd argue that reading a long piece (especially if it contains an illustrative story) is much more memorable than a summary like this. Yes, sometimes,
by lutusp 14y ago
> Also, I'd argue that reading a long piece (especially if it contains an illustrative story) is much more memorable than a summary like this.
Yes, sometimes, but ...
1. Many people have limited reading time.
2. Many topics can be accurately distilled to a few words with no loss of meaning.
3. Economy of expression is highly esteemed in journalism, and it can often be accomplished with no loss of useful content.
Some tl;dr endeavors fall flat, and/or excise the meat along with the fat. Some succeed admirably.
Many submitted essays seem to have been written by someone who expects to be paid by the word, therefore the more words, the better. Such essays are often greatly improved through distillation.
So, in my humble opinion, no conclusion can be drawn -- each tl;dr effort should be judged on its merits.
I will close with my favorite tl;dr story, in which Woody Allen says, "I took a speed-reading course so I could read 'War and Peace'. It's about Russia."