3 ms·
I realise we're all pedantic hackers here (hell, I consider a good dose of pedantry to be a quality - language should be exact where possible) - but this is har
by swombat 18y ago
I realise we're all pedantic hackers here (hell, I consider a good dose of pedantry to be a quality - language should be exact where possible) - but this is hardly worthy of special discussion. Yes, of course people have this feeling, but there's nothing to talk about.
People will continue to misuse the English language whether or not you use up one of the 25 front page slots with this moan. Get used to it, that's the way the world goes.
Move along. Nothing to see here.
- jacquesm 18y agoso, "language should be exact where possible" and "People will continue to misuse the English language whether or not you use up one of the 25 front page slots with this moan." That's a pretty strong contradiction. then "Move along. Nothing to see here." What's wrong with discussion, I did not place this 'in the 25 front page slots', the accumulated votes + the front page algorithm did that, no need to attack me personally for that. "move along, nothing to see here." to me smacks of trying to stifle discussion, if you did not want to discuss it then why bother writing what you did ? Or is that your way of saying you should have the last word on this ? For me the difference between a startup and some trial project is a major decider in whether or not I'm going to spend time on reviewing something. The items that have been labelled 'start-up' on HN sometimes are worthy of the term, but quite frequently - and not to get anybody's goat here - the term trial balloon or some other term would be more applicable. It would be nice if the distinction was a bit more clear, if not before long 'start-up' will be just another buzz-word on the ignore list and that would be a waste. I think real start-ups deserve all the attention and help they can get.
- swombat 18y agoso, "language should be exact where possible" and "People will continue to misuse the English language whether or not you use up one of the 25 front page slots with this moan." /me remembers to emphasize "WHERE POSSIBLE" "The web" is not a place where it is possible to enforce exact language. Hopefully that's not news to you, otherwise you're in for some rude shocks. What's wrong with discussion What discussion? I see no discussion here, just a moan and a couple of replies moaning along. What discussion could there possibly be on this topic? It's a non-topic. It's not a discussion, it's a moan. Like "Death sucks" or "I hate going to school", this ("People mix up start-ups and projects") is just a useless rant. For me the difference between a startup and some trial project is a major decider in whether or not I'm going to spend time on reviewing something. The items that have been labelled 'start-up' on HN sometimes are worthy of the term, but quite frequently - and not to get anybody's goat here - the term trial balloon or some other term would be more applicable. Do you think people will change their posting behaviours because of this rant? Of course they won't. if not before long 'start-up' will be just another buzz-word on the ignore list and that would be a waste "Start-up" IS a buzz-word. Have been for about 10 years now. I think real start-ups deserve all the attention and help they can get. Exactly, so stop wasting this space debating terminology and leave that front page spot open to actual start-up news.