3 ms·

Github needs a "Human Trust" score where "AI Slop" label applied to a PR reduces the score and denies all PR's for the next X hours, delay increasing exponentia

by lenkite 4mo ago

Github needs a "Human Trust" score where "AI Slop" label applied to a PR reduces the score and denies all PR's for the next X hours, delay increasing exponentially for every PR labelled with "AI Slop". Repeated "AI Slop" labels given by a maintainer reduces "Human Trust" Score like dropping off a cliff. Every successful merge for a PR spread across N days slowly increases "Human Trust" score. (So a slow of fake merged PR's cannot fake increase Human Trust score). Just like the real world, Human Trust should be hard to gain and easy to lose. If your Human Trust Score becomes negative due to too much "AI Slop", then you are banned from all PR submissions for a quarter. Your profile picture is also replaced with the Robot Identicon to indicate to the world that your human brain has been replaced by AI and urgent health-check is needed.

Terr_ 4mo ago
That could be abused the other way against well-intentioned humans. Simply let someone accumulate PRs at a not-abusive rate, and then once enough exist falsely report them all in a day. > banned from all PR submissions So then the person can't even make a PR against their own repository? Or when we're there a maintainer, known contributor, or a member of an organization that might be their workplace?
- lenkite 4mo ago
  "AI slop" reporting also comes with a budget. You can only apply N "AI slop" labels to a user per week. Obviously ban is only for PRs against other repositories belonging to different users/organization. Not PRs towards same user/org.