4 ms·
I don't know if journalists are mad because they don't get into startups themselves, only cover them. Or because journalism has been fairly marginalized (sad bu
by untog 14y ago
I don't know if journalists are mad because they don't get into startups themselves, only cover them. Or because journalism has been fairly marginalized (sad but true) and is undergoing some major transitions... I don't know.
Not to defend the article (which I agree a little too snarky, but will get pageviews) but I imagine that working as a journalist covering startups is a thoroughly depressing existence. If it's anything like my (non-journalistic) interactions with the industry then every interesting, earnest startup founder you meet will be matched by five other over-confident blowhards selling bad ideas with bad polish on top.
I know that I would never have the patience to actually interview people like that, so sometimes I give credit to tech journalists just for not spontaneous combusting at conferences.
- DannyBee 14y agoI can't upvote this comment enough. Your explanation reminds me of why people hate lawyers so much. For every 1 good lawyer I meet, I meet 5 truly horrible ones. The same is true of startup founders i've met. The responses you usually see to pointing out someone's idea is horrible is "well, it's hard to predict what ideas will be big, so you don't really know it's horrible. You may be wrong". Given most ideas are horrible, and most startups fail, the onus is on the guy telling you how "rottenfood.com: Rotten food shipped same-day to your door!" will be the next big thing to provide evidence his idea is not horrible. Usually this "evidence" is in the form of talking points: "Rotten Food is a 500 million dollar industry just ripe for disruption". Then when it fails "the idea was good, but the time wasn't right, but it was a valuable learning experience". No! The idea was not good. It was horrible. The fact that you think otherwise tells me it was not a valuable learning experience, because you didn't learn the most important thing. I can't even write up this comment without it turning into all snark, so i'm just going to leave it to the tech journalists :)