3 ms·
I think people are missing the biggest takeaway: everyone wants to get rich writing Rails apps in a weekend that really don't contribute, that our brightest min
by bdcravens 14y ago
I think people are missing the biggest takeaway: everyone wants to get rich writing Rails apps in a weekend that really don't contribute, that our brightest minds are being wasted. Rather than creating things that are truly innovative, we're barely iterating on things that were barely iterations to being with.
- tptacek 14y agoThe world is full of weekend-hard Rails apps that can both contribute and make loads of money. The problem has nothing at all to do with engineering, and everything to do with echo-chamber marketing. The apps don't need to be harder to write; they just need to solve problems for nurses or attorneys or auto mechanics instead of early-adopter tech consumers and advertisers. David Heinemeier Hansson put this as succinctly as anyone in the world could, and at YC startup school! - "build something useful and charge money for it; it's not rocket surgery." But despite that advice instantly getting pegged to the top of HN, a huge number of would-be entrepreneurs have ignored it for years. Dan Lyons has correctly spotted the symptoms but wildly missed the mark on the diagnosis.
- peacemaker 14y agoWhile I agree with the quote "build something useful and charge money for it; it's not rocket surgery." I think it over simplifies things. What exactly is "useful" anyway? How do I find a useful idea? Who do I charge for it? How much should I charge? I think the real trick is finding that idea.
- tptacek 14y agoA good way to find out if an idea is useful is to charge money for it. People come up with elaborate schemes to avoid doing that because asking for money and being turned down is a form of rejection, and rejection stings. I'll tell you from 15 years in startups, including long stints in companies I didn't run that weren't even part of my identity with customer prospects I didn't even care about: rejection always stings, will probably always sting, and you will subconsciously (to your great detriment) always avoid situations with potential reject even though you know you need to not do that. The result is a system that converges on stories that can pick up 6-18 months of funding runway without ever demonstrating value from real customers. There are businesses that need to boot up without asking for money from customers, but they're not common, and when you find one, it will be very clear why you'd defer revenue, and the answer won't have anything to do with monetizing eyeballs.
- bdcravens 14y agoI wasn't picking on Rails specifically, and I do really agree with DHH on selling as opposed to "social traction". You get to a very real point (kinda counteracts what I literally said, but gets to the heart of the point I was trying to make): don't play the startup lottery. Real apps, the apps you generate real revenue on, are those that don't require Series A.
- bitcartel 14y agoFunny, 10 years ago, everybody wanted to get rich by getting into investment banking and work in credit derivatives, even if they would admit to you over a drink in the pub that they didn't actually understand what they were doing. Now we talk about the wasted talent. I guess the moral of the story is that easy money kills dreams.