3 ms·
How can you tell what one is? Reddit in 2010? Facebook in 2005? IRC in 1999?
by inigyou 5mo ago
How can you tell what one is? Reddit in 2010? Facebook in 2005? IRC in 1999?
- actionfromafar 5mo agoI think I would be fine with a positive enumeration. Some ideas for serving content: - purely random - sponsored but without user tracking (like old school TV ads) - sponsored for user selected geographical area feed - sponsored for user current location geographical area feed - follow "friends" or influencers - purely timeline - discussion boards - timeline (IRC like) - threaded - user votes (not magic platform votes) - follow keywords
- inigyou 5mo agoSo Hacker News wouldn't be allowed?
- actionfromafar 5mo agoI think it should be, maybe I'm missing some aspect, I just cooked up a simple list of rules on the spot, sheesh :-D Edit: huh, I'm probably stupid, but can you explain more?
- inigyou 5mo agoHN uses magical platform votes.
- rootusrootus 5mo agoAnd it should be transparent about it. When Dan uses a magic lever, it should be visible.
- inigyou 5mo agoWould Facebook be okay if all the Nazi propaganda posts were tagged "Facebook boosted this post"?
- actionfromafar 5mo agoIf they did boost it, why shouldn't they tell us?
- inigyou 5mo agoWould that be all that's required to make it okay?
- actionfromafar 5mo agoNo, I don't think so.
- amanaplanacanal 5mo agoIf the users chooses what they are shown and the order they are shown in, then it's fine. If the platform chooses, then it's not, because they will always choose what creates the most engagement.
- inigyou 5mo agoSo HN should be banned
- amanaplanacanal 5mo agoNot necessarily. Just fix the algorithm. Showing all submissions by time should be ok, showing all submissions by number of upvotes should be ok if the user chooses that.
- inigyou 5mo agoThe platform can also add ghost upvotes and downvotes and censor upvotes and downvotes.
- actionfromafar 5mo agoThat could be penalized, ultimately by breaking up the company and selling it in parts.
- inigyou 5mo agoWell, yeah, it could be. Is that your proposal?
- deleted 5mo ago[deleted]
- micromacrofoot 5mo agoThat's the problem, recommendation algorithms on networks beyond a certain scale should be publicly auditable. If they're not, I should be able to opt-out of them.
- infinitezest 5mo agoIs heroin the same as beer? Who even knows.