4 ms·
No way. The UI is a gimmick. Watch the video. Seeing him use it does not lead me to believe this will make my life better at all. There are far too many intric
by whalesalad 14y ago
No way. The UI is a gimmick. Watch the video.
Seeing him use it does not lead me to believe this will make my life better at all. There are far too many intricate gestures and complex interactions.
This UI does not solve any problems. The interactive tiles that are essentially miniature versions of the full app are just noisy. Part of the beauty of this new mobile experience that recent smartphones have cultivated is modal interaction. One app for one thing. I launch my music app and it's full screen with large touch buttons that are easy to use. I switch to another app to immerse myself in reading or responding to emails.
I never need to do this from my homescreen, let alone see or interact with all of it at once.
The ambient photo stuff is neat but also entirely useless.
Nothing about this is radical. It's just a layer of more playful paint on yet another mobile platform.
Why is everyone so fucking concerned with multitasking?
My android-fanboy buddy showed me something the other day that made me chuckle. He says, "dude, look at this." He proceeded to load a video from the media library, and started to play it in some kind of picture-in-picture mode where it was floating above everything else on the phone. Then he tells me, "how cool is this?! you can use your phone while the video plays." my simple response, to which he had no answer: "when is that useful?" It's not! And he proceeded to admit that, albeit with his tail between his legs. I didn't say that to be an asshole, I just think that these days people are far too excited about gimmicks and useless customizations. He then went on to say something like "well what about if you want to watch a youtube video and also reply to some text messages?" ... society is doomed.
- whatshisface 14y ago>"when is that useful?" I would like to be able to listen to youtube music videos while doing other tasks.
- jasonkolb 14y ago"Why is everyone so fucking concerned with multitasking?" Some of us can do more than one thing at a time, some things I do require it. Don't be so myopic.
- douglasisshiny 14y agoActually, current scientific evidence says otherwise.
- viraptor 14y agoActually I'd like it if I could respond to an incoming message over whatever app is running right now, without switching away. This would be useful for videos, games without a proper pause state saving, almost any application really. There's also the problem that comes up every other week for me: the phone number I want to call is in a picture / not selectable / selecting is completely broken due to some onmouseover handler. It still happens from time to time and I really wish I had an ability to see both apps (the one with the information and the dialer) at the same time. Video over other things seems less useful though... So yes, I'd like to see a little bit easier multitasking because not all apps/pages are properly taking advantage of the UI possibilities yet. And I'm talking about simple things like href=tel:...
- alien_acorn 14y agoIf you are on Android, try Hovernote to address the unselectable phone number case. Type the number into the hovering note, then copy/paste from the note.
- pkulak 14y agoPlease don't call Samsung gimmicks "Android". Nothing Samsung has ever shoehorned into Android has been useful. And efficient multi-tasking _can_ be very nice. For example, Android has a dedicated app-switching button. One tap shows you a list of your last-used apps, about 5 visible without scrolling. It makes it insanely fast to swap between apps. On iOS you have to double tap a physical button. If not that, then you can tap it once and select your next app from the home screen. The problem now is that because that one button has been overloaded, it always has to wait and make sure there's no second tap coming before it can take you to the springboard. That small delay is pretty annoying once you get used to Android, which isn't limited to one button.
- mannkind 14y agoReally? Is it really that different to double tap a hardware button than it is to tap one? You must feel the same way about single-vs-double clicking a mouse then, I suppose ... because it's the exact same thing.
- pkulak 14y agoNo, it's not the exact same thing. Single tapping a mouse is selection. There's no waiting for the second tap because an item can be "selected" for a fraction of a second before it's opened. A home button can't take you home for a fraction of a second before the multitasking bar opens, so every home press has to wait before it can know what you intend it to do.
- MatthewPhillips 14y agoI haven't used a Sailfish device so I can't say how useful it is or is not. But you are dead wrong about there not being use cases to having information on your homescreen. I'm currently using a WP8 device and "pinning" is very useful there. Here's an example I used today. I ordered tickets to a movie on Fandango and then pinned the receipt to my homescreen so that when I went I got to the theater I could easily bring up the QR code and print out my tickets. I also use pinning when I'm traveling and have restaurants, attractions, etc. that I want to check out pinned to the start screen. It's immensely valuable.
- whalesalad 14y agoI don't doubt you. In fact, I agree with you in the usefulness of having a dynamic home screen. That being said ... I disagree that each of those little things should be interactive to the level that they are on Sailfish. Not only that, but it appears to be one of their main selling points. I'm not sold. For the record, I like Windows Phone and prefer it to Android.
- merlincorey 14y agoAs an emacs user, I don't think modal is the one true way. Nothing in emacs is modal (though focus will switch on its own when required, you can move back to where you were if needed).