2 ms·
I just don't understand why, given all the other problems we have, marijuana is important enough to prohibit even if there were some benefit to doing so. It's
by rdl 14y ago
I just don't understand why, given all the other problems we have, marijuana is important enough to prohibit even if there were some benefit to doing so. It's clearly not a terrible scourge, even with zero benefit ascribed to reducing the scale of drug war, enforcement costs, civil liberties, civil war in Mexico, huge prison population, etc.
Especially once you factor in all the costs of prohibition, it makes no sense. If marijuana were legal today, it wouldn't be worth prohibiting; at most it might be worth requiring standard disclosures of THC percentages and maybe restricting to 18+, and specific driving or other professional restrictions.
Because it's banned, the whole issue gets attention way out of proportion to the actual importance.
- dmix 14y agoThe DEA/DHS are the governments consultants on drug policy. These agencies have a strong incentives to keep the charade going. Especially now with all of the overseas military operations ending and a ton of technology and government workers needing employment.
- tptacek 14y agoThis is sophomore dorm room thinking. 49-51% of Americans do not believe that marijuana should remain criminal because they've been brainwashed by the DEA. I'm comfortable telling you what isn't the reason for criminalization (government brainwashing), but less comfortable positing reasons for it. But if I had to guess, I'd say this: People are inherently loss-averse; it's a fundamental part of our psychology. Most people (I think correctly, but I understand that reasonable people disagree) judge that making cannabis use as widespread as alcohol and tobacco would be a net negative. They worry about that, and it clouds their judgement about the ongoing costs of enforcement, especially because most people never come into contact with the direct costs of enforcement.
- rdl 14y ago49-51% of Americans don't need to be brainwashed by DEA. There are some entrenched interests who actually fight for the drug war -- police, corrections officers, etc. -- out of their own self-interest and a misguided belief that it's the only way to save society. They contribute a lot of money to the "keep drugs illegal" marketing and research, which has worked for so long to keep the general public pro-prohibition. (I think 80-90% of people have no real direct opinion on the drug war either way, except from what they're told by the prohibitionists. "It will harm our children, keep your kids away from drugs" is a powerful message. Racism was a powerful tool in getting prohibition enacted in the first place.) This is why I think LEAP (Law Enforcement Against Prohibition) is one of the most important anti-prohibition organizations out there.
- tptacek 14y agoThe police aren't fighting in favor of the drug war. The police in Chicago favor drug tickets. The commissioner of state police in Indiana (ffs!) just came out against the drug war. Corrections officers, maybe, but I dispute that ordinary Americans pay attention to the interests and positions of corrections officers the way they do police.
- rdl 14y agoNot local police anymore (although 20-30 years ago, I think they did support it). Federal, and the entire economy built up around the drug prohibition industry. It's an embarrassingly small industry, but it really cares about this issue, which means it is a political issue. Just like 99% of people don't care that much about farm subsidies, but 1% stake their votes and budgets on it, so it persists. In California, the corrections officers are one of the 3 strongest unions (actually, MORE influential than the police, second only to teachers I think). It's pretty insane. No one really cares about them, except that they have enough money and votes to be a major political force. I think the drug war as a whole will be ended in 10-20 years, with prohibition at the level of stopping illegal/untaxed cigarettes today, and starting by removing marijuana from the schedules and moving a fair number of schedule I to schedule II (MDMA, in particular). But it's interesting to know why and how we got to where we are.
- tptacek 14y agoThe whole thrust of the article we're commenting on is that marijuana is being decriminalized. Decriminalization and normalization of cannabis is inevitable. Yes, it's happening at the state level instead of federally, but that's how stuff like this is supposed to work; eventually, the majority of states that empty their holding cells of petty cannabis offenders will bully the remaining states that criminalize it with some a federal law of some sort. It's obvious and banal to point out that there are government actors who oppose legalization. Of course there are. There would have to be, or marijuana would already be legal. But it is not true to suggest that law enforcement uniformly opposes legalization. The law enforcement bodies that tend to actually matter in policy decisions --- state and large urban police forces --- are caving on this issue. They can't afford enforcement anymore. For what it's worth, I do not believe that MDMA and LSD and opiates will be decriminalized. At best, they'll obtain the status fentanyl has today: drugs that are prescribable, but only under close scrutiny.
- rdl 14y agoRemoving marijuana from the drug war still lets them continue to fight/lose vs. meth, cocaine, and opiates. The screwed up thing is that the opiate war is actually contributing to losing in Afghanistan (i.e. a real war).