3 ms·
Generally speaking, I expect that legal cannabis will tend to cut down on alcohol use, and I would tend to see this as a good thing. Cannabis tends to be less
by Symmetry 14y ago
Generally speaking, I expect that legal cannabis will tend to cut down on alcohol use, and I would tend to see this as a good thing.
Cannabis tends to be less addictive than alcohol, it's pretty much impossible to kill yourself with an overdose, and people intoxicated with it tend to overestimate how impaired they are rather than underestimate it like with alcohol.
I've seen a bunch of different studies using different methodologies to come up with various rankings of drugs by degree of harm [1][2][3], but every one of them rates cannabis as safer than alcohol.
EDIT: I expect that the "gateway drug" effect is due to people finding out that pot is much less dangerous than they are led to believe. People have always heard that using illegal drugs would kill them, then find that their friends are using it safely and assume that all illegal drugs are similarly safe.
[1]http://tlc.howstuffworks.com/family/drug-ranking.htm http://tlc.howstuffworks.com/family/drug-ranking.htm
[2]http://bmjopen.bmj.com/content/2/4/e000774.full http://bmjopen.bmj.com/content/2/4/e000774.full
[3]http://medicalmarijuana.procon.org/view.resource.php?resourceID=004477 http://medicalmarijuana.procon.org/view.resource.php?resourc...
- tptacek 14y agoPeople intoxicated with cannabis may be overestimating their impairment because smoking cannabis is a crime, which is a factor that is cancelled out by legalization. I know from hanging out with smokers that concern about degree of impairment tends to come up only when contact with law enforcement is a possibility.
- drivebyacct2 14y agoSo people don't smoke and drive because they don't want to be caught doing something illegal. Seeing as DUI is still illegal in Washington, I don't see how this changes anything. Unless you're saying that because cannabis is legal I'm going to think that a cop is more likely to let me go, or be less likely to check me or what? The legality of cannabis use doesn't change the likelihood of me getting pulled over, no? Or am I misunderstanding where you're coming from?
- tptacek 14y agoYes, I am saying that when cannabis is legal, its users are no longer going to be continuously paranoid that the mere detection of its presence is going to be enough to have them imprisoned.
- drivebyacct2 14y agoRight, (barring the discussion about the differences in impairment between cannabis and alcohol...) those are the same type of people that think they can get away with drinking and driving. They're arrogant, selfish people. But I don't really buy that they're sitting at home being good law abiding citizens waiting one hour for every drink or one hour for every toke before driving to Taco Bell right now, only to abandon that once it's legal.
- tptacek 14y agoNo, I disagree. People think they can get away with drinking and driving because they almost overwhelmingly can get away with drinking and driving, and because the penalties for DUI conviction are routinized (they're more severe than a ticket but, barring injuries, less severe than any felony). Neither is the case for cannabis. If you're pulled over and your car reeks of weed, your car will be searched, and if cannabis turns up, everyone in the car is likely to be arrested. Your prosecution afterwards will not be routine; if you're found guilty, it is very likely to cost you your job in a way a DUI conviction isn't.
- drivebyacct2 14y ago>People think they can get away with drinking and driving because they almost overwhelmingly can get away with drinking and driving The legality of cannabis does not affect the likelihood of me getting pulled over so I don't understand. Or are you saying "keeping your job and not getting a felony = getting away with it"? I mean, how many people are you imagining are cool with a DUI conviction and not a, I don't know, whatever it is if you get pulled over with weed in the car, possession+DUI?
- Symmetry 14y agoWell, according to an article I read in New Scientist a while ago, people who were given cannabis and asked to perform drive in a simulator tended to slow down enough to nearly overcome their impairment, while people given alcohol didn't tend to slow down at all. And in fact people in the study who were given moderate amounts of both alcohol and cannabis tended to do driver better than people who had just taken alcohol. And anecdotally, the one time I ate a pot brownie I was convinced that I must be swaying back and forth until my friends convinced me I wasn't. The experience started with 20 minutes of horrid vertigo which I gather was a pretty idiosyncratic reaction, so take that with a grain of salt.