3 ms·
1) is a question of business model. If they want to sell for less than cost, then they need to factor in that others can unlock the device, without paying, and
by dalke 14y ago
1) is a question of business model. If they want to sell for less than cost, then they need to factor in that others can unlock the device, without paying, and use the device for something other than their store.
Just like they factor in that people might buy a machine and do nothing with it.
1) also has a problem in that is puts a post-sale obligation on the company. Suppose the company goes out of business; can people unlock the device? For that matter, do they have to provide telephone/email support in order to unlock, or will postal mail (with 6-8 weeks response time, to the factory in Korea) suffice?
As for 2), you rightly point out that there are reasonable concerns. The submitted proposal to the members of the German Pirate Party says "Weiterhin darf die freie Softwareinstallation nicht zu einem Verlust der Gewährleistung oder anderen Nachteilen für den Verbraucher führen" - Furthermore the installation of Free Software does not result in the loss of warranty or other disadvantages for the consumer."
Though it also has clauses which exclude "devices for industrial and safety-critical applications as well as devices where erroneous or malicious software can cause direct physical damage." Your observation fits right in the middle of those two.
I think it's not so complicated though. Do overclockers sue Intel when an overclocked chip melts? I think that excluding the use of "erroneous or malicious software" from warranty coverage is enough.