4 ms·
Everything that's needed besides letting computers talk to each other, that is. With ipv4 you have a two tier internet. Computers talk to servers, servers talk
by inigyou 5mo ago
Everything that's needed besides letting computers talk to each other, that is.
With ipv4 you have a two tier internet. Computers talk to servers, servers talk to servers, computers can't talk to computers so every video call must be routed through a server.
- ikari_pl 5mo agoAnd wasn't that THE POINT of the internet and it's decentralised design?
- inigyou 5mo agoYes. Letting anyone talk to anyone was the point of the internet. It's been co-opted by these massive centralising forces and you know what? They're right. With IPv4 everything has to be centralised, we don't even have the faintest chance to avoid it. With IPv6 at least we have a chance to take it back. Some people will mention stateful firewalls. They're pretty easy to holepunch through because you just need each side to send a packet to the other, then each firewall sees it as an outgoing connection and allows it. It's nothing like IPv4 NAT.
- somat 5mo agoThe comparison between a statefull firewall and NAT is often because they feel like they are doing the same thing from a mechanical point of view. For example here is how to achieve the same result in PF, note the single additional operator needed to specify nat. block in on $EXT_IF #NAT pass in on $INT_IF to any rdr-to $EXT_IF #statefullfirewall pass in on $INT_IF to any
- ghusto 5mo agoI hear this as a cited as a benefit of IPv6 a lot. Honest question: Isn't this at least a privacy issue, at most a security issue? SLAAC seems like what we already have with extra, breakable steps, which doesn't effectively address the privacy issue anyway.
- TheDong 5mo agoWhere's the privacy issue? That the server can figure out that two computers in the same house are different since your laptop and phone no longer share the same ipv4 address but instead have two ipv6 address? Your phone and laptop can just have multiple ipv6 addresses and rotate through them regularly... as apple does by default https://support.apple.com/en-ca/guide/security/seccb625dcd9/web https://support.apple.com/en-ca/guide/security/seccb625dcd9/... Security? NAT is not a firewall, you need a firewall, and switching to IPv6 does not remove your firewall. Before IPv6: The server gets "1.2.3.4:56789" for your device. After IPv6: the server gets "1:2:3:4::56" or whatever for your device. In either case, if the server makes a connection to 1.2.3.4:56789 or 1:2:3:4::56, your router sees the packet and firewalls the connection. Cool. Want to give me a concrete example of where IPv6 is hurting my privacy or security, because I've been using it for over a decade with zero mishaps, zero privacy issues, zero security issues (to my knowledge at least)
- inigyou 5mo agoThey used to recommend using the MAC address. This was ok 30 years ago when a computer sat in an office on a desk but it makes it very easy to fingerprint a moving computer as it moves across different networks. Using a random address (Privacy Extensions) solves this problem though, but do we expect everyone to know what that is and check it's enabled? Mine wasn't enabled by default (on Linux) and I only noticed when a bittorrent site warned me.
- throw0101a 5mo agoAs mentioned by GP, Apple enables privacy extensions on all their OSes: * https://support.apple.com/en-ca/guide/security/seccb625dcd9/web https://support.apple.com/en-ca/guide/security/seccb625dcd9/... As does Windows (since Vista), and Android (8+). So why are we still talking about this?
- frantathefranta 5mo agoCould you publicly shame the distro that had that issue? Pretty sure it should be the default (on NixOS at least it is).