3 ms·
This feels like a joke, right? Short, generative midi clips, for real world money? I thought at first maybe the shop thing was like a visual gag, but, no, it's
by vegadw 4mo ago
This feels like a joke, right? Short, generative midi clips, for real world money? I thought at first maybe the shop thing was like a visual gag, but, no, it's actually going to stripe.
There's a million better generative MIDI tools out there, and the vast vast majority are free. I can't fathom making this and not being embarrassed, let alone anyone actually spending money on the site.
I would normally reserve such harsh criticism but as sporkl points out, this seems to be some LLM generated drive-by money-grab mess.
I do worry that maybe OP is like a teenager and I'm coming off overly harsh, but even if that's the case, then OP needs to learn what actually makes a product differentiate itself and how to actually appeal to a target audience. This ain't it chief, as a musician, I find it actively offensive.
- midi_finder 3mo agoThere are no LLMs behind the scenes, that is a guarantee. I've been composing music for 15 years. Can you show me the free "better generative MIDI tools" that exist? I'd appreciate some constructive feedback!
- vegadw 3mo agoOrca, Nestup, https://krasse.itch.io/wavebots-editor https://krasse.itch.io/wavebots-editor, https://github.com/hisschemoller/music-pattern-generator https://github.com/hisschemoller/music-pattern-generator, https://github.com/chalkwalk/arps-euclidya https://github.com/chalkwalk/arps-euclidya If you use Cardnial as a VST you can use any of hundreds of generative sequencers it has. Browsing midi clips compared to something with parameters that you can tweak, like all of these have seems infinitely preferably than wandering through a sea of MIDI clips.