4 ms·
> the fact is that advertising is the only way the vast majority of the Internet can exist This is a bit of an overstatement, I think. There is certainly some
by _delirium 14y ago
> the fact is that advertising is the only way the vast majority of the Internet can exist
This is a bit of an overstatement, I think. There is certainly some good ad-supported stuff, and maybe it's the "vast majority of the Internet" if counted by sheer volume, but if weighted by information quality, I would put it closer to maybe half of the Internet. For my own browsing, probably more like 20-30% of the sites I visit regularly are supported by ad revenue, but I'll admit that's probably low. The rest are not there primarily to make direct revenue through selling ad space, though they might be connected to a profit motive in some other way.
Some in that category: Wikipedia, HN, a whole bunch of *.edu stuff, tumblr, technical blogs run by companies (MSDN Blogs, Googlers' blogs, lots of startups' blogs), Amazon, websites run by think-tanks like Cato or Hoover, arXiv. In fact I think the only ad-supported sites I visit regularly are newspaper websites, Facebook, StackExchange, and Google's properties.
- Evbn 14y agoHN and corporate blogs are all ad supported, just not third-party ad-network supported.
- pyre 14y agoI think that it's generally understood that we mean '3rd party ads' when referring to advertisement (at least in this context). Google's blogs are obviously ads for its products, but you go there knowing this, yet still want to read the content anyways. When you go to NYTimes to read about world news and get shown an ad for a blender, that's entirely different.
- lsc 14y agoThat... is a big stretch. That's like saying my personal blog is ad-supported because it advertises me. I mean, it would be more correct to call it an ad than to call it ad-supported. Same with news.ycombinator.com; it does a lot to advertise ycombinator.com, sure... but calling it ad-supported is really a stretch from what most people think that phrase means. I mean, if we are going that far, every article published where the author was compensated mostly in ego (which is to say, nearly everything written) is ad-supported.
- _delirium 14y agoYeah, that's the caveat I was trying to add with "connected to a profit motive in some other way". If an SaaS startup writes a technical blog, they're probably doing it in part because they hope it'll help bring in some more paying customers. But they aren't typically hoping to monetize the blog itself as their revenue-generating product, through AdSense or BlogAds or similar.