3 ms·
Yes, the pleasures of life (wine, music, books, sex, spiritual experience) don't change all that much I'm not so sure. Those pleasures all continue to exist bu
by petercooper 14y ago
Yes, the pleasures of life (wine, music, books, sex, spiritual experience) don't change all that much
I'm not so sure. Those pleasures all continue to exist but except for wine, the way we enjoy or practice most of these would be alien to people of 100 years ago. It's not the concepts that change but their expression.
Throw two 20-somethings from 1912 into a common modern scenario of doing shots before you go out, hitting a nightclub full of techno music, laser lights and people 'grinding', then coming home and indulging in some pre-maritial anal sex (just to be safe) and you might as well have thrown them on a different planet.
Life in 100 years will seem similarly bizarre and intense to us now. I think the author of the article has a certain notion of what 'cool' is but I think radical changes in expression and society are also 'cool' - they're just not jetpacks or spacesuits.
- notJim 14y agoAnd yet, starting just 8 years later: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flapper http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flapper I think it's easy to overestimate the difference between people in the past and ourselves. The lack of shame with which people pursue their pleasures now may be different, but it's silly to think people 100 years ago didn't enjoy getting smashed and having sex.
- robryan 14y agoI think the issue is that when doing a comparison we are comparing todays common culture and our own experiences with the prevailing generalisations of the past. Who knows in 50 to 100 years time how people will generalise our current culture and compare it to however people are then.
- Surio 14y agoAfter the double take/uneasy giggle at the choice of word to describe women (in the 1920s), I looked at the article. One main difference that stands out for me is that the type of behaviour patterns described by the OP above (booze, grind, etc.) would be classed as "typical" from today's point of view, the "flapper" behaviour pattern above wouldn't have been "typical" in that usual sense of the word in those times (would it probably be tame from today's stand point?). Anecdotally, it would have been, at best fringe, and dare I say, restricted to (perhaps) the wealthy. Someone also mentioned roman orgies. That would have been restricted to the wealthy, upper class too and would not have been classed as "typical"? Therefore, the OP's point, namely, " the way we enjoy or practice most of these would be alien to people of 100 years ago. It's not the concepts that change but their expression." is relevant IMO. And usually that is where clash of the generations originate from?
- corporalagumbo 14y agoRoman orgies is a bullshit myth. Christian smear propaganda to discredit Roman culture.
- michaelochurch 14y agoWell, yes. Taleb's point was that life's basic needs and pleasures don't change. My counter-point (which was in agreement with what you're saying) is that more people can enjoy those things, and there are more ways for them to do so. Also, I don't think there's a time in history when alcohol/drug use and premarital anal sex weren't common. All of that is ancient. People tend to think of sexual norms in the 1837-1967 era (and even then, only middle-class and higher, and more in polite myth than actuality) as "traditional" but that's not how things "always" were.
- hcarvalhoalves 14y ago1912? Alcohol, party, anal sex... You could be talking about Rome and it would still be the same! You think it's different just because there's techno? Come on!
- eli_gottlieb 14y agoThrow two 20-somethings from 1912 into a common modern scenario of doing shots before you go out, hitting a nightclub full of techno music, laser lights and people 'grinding', then coming home and indulging in some pre-maritial anal sex (just to be safe) and you might as well have thrown them on a different planet. This is not how modern twenty-somethings actually behave, except for blatantly stereotypical hipsters.
- JoeAltmaier 14y agoAgreed. What hubris to imagine modern 20-somethings invented alcohol, music and sex! In 1912 radio was being invented, Gibson was going strong making instruments, Picasso was shocking the world with disturbing art, women were upsetting men by wearing their clothes or dressing Oriental... and lots of sex was going on.