3 ms·
A very simple thought experiment: A rap artist is hired by a label to create an album. Said artist later dies. The label goes bankrupt soon thereafter, or perh
by angersock 14y ago
A very simple thought experiment:
A rap artist is hired by a label to create an album. Said artist later dies. The label goes bankrupt soon thereafter, or perhaps simply folds up shop and leaves the business without auctioning off its assets.
I have produced a copy of the album, which I host at my own cost from my server, once these events have transpired. There is no reasonable "victim" left for this crime of infringement, and indeed I'm helping to reduce the scarcity of this product in the world.
While somewhat contrived, this thought experiment is not particularly far off from reality.
- chasing 14y agoNo, it's pretty far off from reality. It's an extreme edge case that doesn't at all justify pirating Photoshop.
- angersock 14y agoAh, you're correct--we were talking about software mainly, not music. Software companies never go out of business without selling off their assets, and it's the extreme edge-case where people continue to distribute the works. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abandonware This truly seldom happens.
- Kerrick 14y agoAgain, abandonware does not justify pirating Photoshop, a product that is constantly updated by a very active company.
- Karunamon 14y agoSee also abandonware or emulation of older systems. It's technically illegal for me to go download a copy of System Shock, but the company that made it is long gone, and the company that bought their assets isn't doing anything with it. Illegal? Sort of. Immoral? Not really.
- Domenic_S 14y ago> There is no reasonable "victim" left for this crime of infringement The victim is the artist's heirs.