2 ms·
I've recently done some work for a startup that is developing a highly comparable product. I strongly doubt their "works on any car since 1995" claim. While OB
by skrebbel 14y ago
I've recently done some work for a startup that is developing a highly comparable product.
I strongly doubt their "works on any car since 1995" claim. While OBD-II has been an official standard for very long, not all cars support it equally well at all. We've had serious trouble getting it to work with A-brand cars made in e.g. 1999.
Therefore, I believe that them making this claim can mean one of two things:
- They're lying
- Their "prototype" has seen little field testing at this point.
That said, honesty be told, we've been testing in Europe, where the OBD standard has been adopted later. My impression is that moj.io is a North-American only product. Maybe this makes all the difference.
Additionally, however, "Virtual Mechanic" based on OBD-II alone is going to be a half-assed feature (to my understanding). OBD-II contains little more error reporting than that related to emission (i.e. your engine). If your airbag or your breaks malfunction, then this may only be reported through manufacturer-specific protocols. Most importantly, this would mean that a light in your dashboard may be lit, while the Moj.io app says "Running Great!" I highly doubt that they have implemented all manufacturer-specific protocols to a sufficient extent for this feature to work well. It is technically possible, but it needs either a lot of reverse engineering, or a lot of purchased IP.
I really like the other features (FamilyConnect, etc), though, and how they're presented. Well done!
Still, while I like this approach, and while I want this badly myself (and a lot of moj.io seems better planned, marketed and designed than what I've been involved in), based on the above I have strong doubts.
Now, I understand that this may be hard criticism, and maybe I'm completely wrong about some aspects - I'm no real expert here. So if one of the founders reads this, feel free to correct me!
- jaygiraud 14y agoHi skrebbel, great insights here. moj.io is a spin out of another company called REV Technologies, that has been doing energy telematics for the US Army with its partners at SAIC and Honeywell Aerospace since 2008. REV has extensive experience with CANbus networks and OBD communication. Our prototype moj.io device has the benefit of all that experience, whereby REV has been controlling power converters, inverters, motor controllers, large lithium battery packs and many other high voltage electronics and communicating over both the low, med and high speed CAN networks of both modern and not so modern cars. In regards to the Virtual Mechanic app, you're absolutely right. We know that presently it won't be as extensive on european cars as it will be for North America, which is part of the reason for focusing on the North American market for now. But that is just one app, and probably the least interesting one to the general market of drivers out there. We think the majority of the other apps that we and the dev community will build will only need basic info like odo reading, speed, on/off ignition states and what gear the car is in. So much can be done with that when blended with data from the device's accelerometer, GPS, etc. Jay Thanks for the very informed thinking on this! Great dialog.