5 ms·
This contains the answer for why git won: Mercurial people have "no interest" in it. What that tells me is that you have no interest in working with the commun
by ajross 14y ago
This contains the answer for why git won: Mercurial people have "no interest" in it. What that tells me is that you have no interest in working with the community and contributing to other peoples' projects, most of which use git these days. Sure, if you want a SCM for your own team or your own private use, you can make a strong case for hg being "better". But that's not what SCM is for.
Using it in your own ivory tower isn't going to impress anyone for the simple reason that no one sees it. Instead, people look at the broader world of all the interconnected git archives in the linux and web development communities, get excited, pull repos and learn git. There's just no equivalent in the hg community that I see. You guys have walled yourselves off, and it's killing your software.
- silverbax88 14y agoAs I said, I worked with Git. I am no longer interested in it as a solution. I'm not sure why I (or any programmer) would need to 'get excited' to learn Git. It's pretty easy to understand.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- ajross 14y agoThis still misses the point. It's not a technical problem, and you can't solve it with software. Being able to interoperate with git does nothing to convince users to use your great tool when all the cool people they know are using git. Where are the hg champions? The culture is the point, not the software.
- garenp 14y agoChange the subject much? You missed the point entirely: you took one persons response and generalized it to the entire population of Mercurial users--claiming it is representative of an entire culture of that population. Then, you claim to be in possession of special knowledge as to what "SCM is for".
- dexen 14y ago> It's git that is unfriendly to others... I have some code in Git with my custom patches, with upstream being Hg. `git-hg' works like a charm -- simple, clean etc. etc.. Dunno what you are talking about here. Git provides git-fast-export & git-fast-import as two-way interconnects, with well-defined data formats.
- klibertp 14y ago> Dunno what you are talking about here. I clearly didn't, too, so I deleted the post.
- jlgreco 14y ago1) Tools to do that certainly exist. Nobody really cares about them to make them nicer. 2) Git is trivial to extend. If something for git doesn't exist that does not suggest any sort of arrogant attitude from git, but rather just a total lack of interest from both the developers and the community.
- jiggy2011 14y agoThis seems a little exaggerated. Before git took over there were all kinds of VCS in use including a bunch of proprietary stuff. If most of your work is done with one group of people inside your company and you decide mercurial is a better fit it would seem silly just to go with git because it is popular. Besides the two are similar enough that someone versed in mercurial should be able to learn enough git to be useful quickly enough should it be required.
- ajross 14y agoNo, before git took over there was CVS (and a brief moment when svn looked like it might win, before being forgotten). There still are "all kinds of VCS including a bunch of proprietary stuff". But as before with CVS (and RCS before it) the open source community has picked an overwhelming favorite. And I'm not saying you should choose git because it's better. I'm saying git "won" in the community because it was the choice of people who want to play in the community. Culture matters, and hg's proponents, for whatever reason, are less likely to want to share their stuff.
- jiggy2011 14y agoWell I remember MS Sourcesafe being popular a few years ago. Do hg people "share less" or are there simply less of them? IIRC github allows commits from hg as well as git. And of course not everyone (in fact possibly only the minority) is interested in cloning and issuing pull requests on OSS a huge amount of programming happens internally in corporations where everyone will use whichever VCS is mandated.
- anonymous 14y agoI looked at mercurial once. I didn't start using it, because it has a more complicated vocabulary than git. Git just has a directed acyclic graph and pointers to the nodes of it. That's all. End of story. Mercurial has the concept of a branch, a tag and so on as seemingly separate axiomatic things. It's not as stupid. I like stupid.
- micampe 14y agoSubversion is really simple too: it only has files and directories, branches are directories, tags are directories. I don’t think stupid and simple worked very well in that case. Arguments can be made for both sides, picking a single design decision and saying that that’s obviously better is not going to work. Implementation and (especially in a case like distributed systems) network effects are much stronger than any single isolated design decision.
- anonymous 14y agoSure, I was talking about my situation. And of course, if mercurial could give me more features, I'd probably think twice. However, it's practically equivalent to git. I was comparing git and mercurial, not giving the one true testament to comparison of every possible version control system.
- Aga 14y agoAlbert Einstein is attributed with a great quote: “Everything should be made as simple as possible, but no simpler.” I would argue that in the case of Git it's not about a single design decision. The whole design is very simple and easily understandable. Thus everything can be derived from the design decisions. The design decisions also have clear rationales. "Why something is better" and "why something has "won"" are of course different questions that deserve different answers.
- micampe 14y agoHaving taught Git to a number of people, I disagree that it’s easily understandable. It’s easy to understand the general idea of how it works, but actually productively using it is an entirely different matter. Of course, I may also be a terrible teacher.
- papsosouid 14y ago>Using it in your own ivory tower isn't going to impress anyone for the simple reason that no one sees it Using loaded terms to put down people who use the tool they prefer isn't going to convince anyone that your argument has merit.
- ajross 14y agoMaking style points about bland, cliched[1] metaphors adds even less to the discussion. Seriously? "Ivory Tower" (!) is a forbidden term that should be banned from civil discourse? [1] Now that you've drawn attention to it, I do indeed wish I'd phrased that differently. But certainly not because I hurt someone's feelings...
- papsosouid 14y agoWho said it was forbidden? Or that you hurt anyone's feelings? Your argument is less effective due to the words you used. That is what I said.
- garenp 14y agoSo you "know" "Mercurial people", yet speak of others as coming from an "ivory tower"? Given that you seem to be in possession of special knowledge, why don't you tell us precisely what "SCM is for"?
- samspot 14y agoA lot of us work on closed-source projects you know. Open source is great, but it isn't the whole world.
- ajross 14y agoThe original questions was specifically about why git was so commonly installed on Debian hosts.
- micampe 14y agoUnnecessarily harsh response to a good point. Network effect: many many people pick git because everyone else uses it (and that’s a good reason), thus they never try Mercurial, which may or may not be better suited to their use case.