3 ms·
While some say that understanding the brain at the quantum level is not necessary for achieving human brain-level intelligence, I think it would be much easier
by mtgx 14y ago
While some say that understanding the brain at the quantum level is not necessary for achieving human brain-level intelligence, I think it would be much easier for AI's to have general intelligence if they used a quantum computer. Pattern recognition, answering to questions, understanding language, speech, and thinking up solutions to problems would all be better served by a quantum computer than by anything else these guys can make.
- lukevdp 14y agoCorrect me if I'm wrong, but aren't the most advanced quantum computers today still grappling with basic arithmetic? What makes a quantum computer better at AI?
- jlgreco 14y agoSome people believe that intelligence, at least of the calibre of human intelligence, must involve some quantum mechanism. This isn't a particularly well-supported idea, few people in academia today believe it to be the case (Roger Penrose being a prominent exception). The thing is, even Penrose isn't proposing anything mystical being done by quantum mechanics. He doesn't like the idea of an algorithmic mind, so he invokes quantum phenomenon to make the mind technically no longer algorithmic. In the real world though, nothing prevents you from doing similar with a desktop computer. You an rig together a (crappy) RNG for your x86 desktop with a serial port and a smoke detector. Penrose isn't trying to suggest that intelligence could not be replicated in man made machines, but rather suggest that the human mind is not restricted as we know purely algorithmic systems to be.
- btipling 14y agoOperating word being "believe", which is basically "guessing". Unless there's data and demonstrable things that work, this is hogwash.
- jlgreco 14y agoAbsolutely. There really is not a good reason to think that human level intelligence cannot be done algorithmicly. No reason to think, other than wishful thinking for some people for whatever reasons, that we are in a different computation class than Turing machines.
- seiji 14y agoPattern recognition, answering to questions, understanding language, speech, and thinking up solutions to problems would all be better served by a quantum computer than by anything else these guys can make. Math or it didn't happen. Speculation without hard facts to back it up is poppycock gobbledygook.
- georgeorwell 14y agoThis kind of research / line of thinking: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quantum_mind https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quantum_mind if true, appears to support his claim, assuming that if we do have quantum minds that they cannot be simulated by non-quantum computers. Roger Penrose is certainly well-respected. I don't have a strong opinion either way.
- seiji 14y agoYes, the addlebrained old man faction has established their own branch of cookery. The simple truth is consciousness, as created by squishy brains, is a physical process. It doesn't rely on quantum non-locality or anything spooky. It's all physical things you can quite easily introspect by poking around (note: reassembly may be more difficult than disassembly). It's fun to think about "what if our thoughts are the universe itself!" but it's so blatantly wrong. It's just one step away from saying consciousness is "mystical" or created by philotic twining.
- jb55 14y agoYou seem to be claiming that quantum mechanical effects are somehow non-physical? It's not too crazy to speculate the brain leveraging quantum mechanicals effects to do something (although I agree, as a prerequisite for consciousness is a pretty big claim). Considering evolution has already leveraged these effects in smell and photosynthesis, which we do have evidence for.
- seiji 14y agoI think some people mix "quantum" and "magic" definitions in their minds. Even mtgx kinda alluded to such above with would all be better served by a quantum computer than by anything else. Everything will -- somehow -- be better. Just add quantum. (protip: go read scott aaronson's relevant articles, papers, monographs, course materials, etc). I don't claim the effects aren't present. I do claim they are unnecessary for the emergence of human level consciousness and the reproduction thereof in silicon.
- robotresearcher 14y agoYou think so? Why? You're making a pretty serious claim without giving any any argument, evidence or citation to support it.