6 ms·
Obama opposes House passage of H.R. 6429
- gsibble 14y agoSweet, delicious irony....
- 001sky 14y agoOne reason it's controversial among Democrats is that the bill would eliminate the 55,000 diversity visas available to citizens of countries with low immigration rates to the United States. -- Sticking point.
- sharkweek 14y agoThe White House response is worth a quick read (PDF --- http://www.whitehouse.gov/sites/default/files/omb/legislative/sap/112/saphr6429r_20121128.pdf http://www.whitehouse.gov/sites/default/files/omb/legislativ...). I spent the majority of my undergrad studying immigration policy, and I can sympathize with the WH's point that chipping away at immigration reform will only complicate broader reforms that eventually need to happen. The bill as written sounds a little unfair as it removes thousands of diversity visas and allows the educated a quick jump to the front of the line. I understand economically why this would be desirable, but it isn't true reform.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- sharkweek 14y agoNo, I'm saying the bill needs to be rewritten to not cannibalize the diversity visas. We need both high skill and low skill labor in massive quantities; and as a country, we're dancing around a ridiculously broken immigration system.
- onetwothreefour 14y agoThe assumption that the DV lottery only brings in low skill labor is both insulting and wrong.
- sharkweek 14y agoYour comment seems a little obtuse. My argument didn't make that assumption. A lottery is random; ideally providing a diverse selection of people across all skill, education and economic levels
- icebraining 14y agoActually, the implicit assumption is that "only DV lottery brings in low skill labor", not that "DV lottery only brings in low skill labor".
- tymathews 14y agoThis shouldn't be a surprise to anyone. Pres. Obama deported more immigrants his first term than Bush.
- dmk23 14y agoI hope all the Obama supporters here still feel good about helping re-elect the man. Rest assured he is still going to support amnesty for unskilled illegals who are more likely to vote Democrat for years to come. EDIT: It is pretty funny how the downvoters fail to acknowledge the basic facts about the politics of the issue and instead fall for the Administration's excuses and rush to condemn "conspiracy theories". There are no theories here, just basic facts.
- hack_edu 14y agoChill out. This has nothing to do with skilled/unskilled, illegal/legal. Its about reform for all of immigration policy, not just those who can already make a living for themselves anywhere. Plus, and I hate to say it, but there's very clearly much greater need (not demand, need) for the sorts of jobs 'unskilled illegals' end up doing than the high-skill (read: class) jobs that this piece of legislation addresses. And stop this immigrants-voting-schtick conspiracy theory. The impact their inclusion would make would doubtly even be within the margin of error. People have much better things to do.
- jdminhbg 14y ago> (not demand, need) Wow.
- hack_edu 14y agoSorry but there is a difference between the two out there in the real world.
- ekm2 14y agoRight,the american economy is in danger of tanking if the country does not hire more janitors.Science and Engineering phds can look after themselves elsewhere,Canada maybe?
- seldo 14y agoIf you kicked out all of the undocumented workers currently working in the US tomorrow, I can absolutely guarantee you that the American economy would immediately collapse. You need more of both.
- nhashem 14y agoFrom the administration's response: "As a part of immigration reform, the Administration strongly supports legislation to attract and retain foreign students who graduate with advanced STEM degrees, to establish a start-up visa for foreign-born entrepreneurs to start businesses and create jobs, and to reform the employment-based immigration system to better meet the needs of the U.S. economy. However, the Administration does not support narrowly tailored proposals that do not meet the President's long-term objectives with respect to comprehensive immigration reform." Essentially this bill "converts" the 55,000 "diversity visas" currently available into "STEM visas." It looks like this bill originated from the Republican party, so I'm wondering why they didn't just write a bill that allocated additional STEM visas without "cannibalizing" the diversity visas.
- btilly 14y agoBecause they want to force Democrats to be on record voting against letting entrepreneurs into the country. The potential for attack ads during the next election cycle matters more in Washington DC than actually getting things done.
- sharkweek 14y agoA little OT : Here's a great example of a bill being written with explicit intent of making anyone who votes against it look like a terrible person: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Protecting_Children_from_Internet_Pornographers_Act_of_2011 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Protecting_Children_from_Intern... Written by Lamar Smith, Mr. Privacy Invader himself -- make sure to read the Privacy issues section of the wiki page
- commandar 14y agoRep. Smith is also responsible for the STEM bill in question here. http://thomas.loc.gov/cgi-bin/bdquery/z?d112:h.r.6429 http://thomas.loc.gov/cgi-bin/bdquery/z?d112:h.r.6429: I've come to associate his name with being a bit of a red flag. EDIT: HN is mangling the hyperlink for some reason. Copy+pasting will get you to the bill.
- temphn 14y agoWhat is the argument for 55000 random visas at a time when the US economy is doing very poorly? Is this a game? US citizenship clearly has market value. Billions of dollars could be raised by turning these into entrepreneur visas or charging per visa (it's not like the US doesn't already do this, but the price is way too low). If we're taxing current citizens, and we have 50% exit taxes, why not entry taxes? When demand exceeds supply increase the price.
- onetwothreefour 14y agoThanks for weighing in with your uninformed opinion on something while also invoking the age old "when the US economy is doing very poorly" straw man which has nothing to do with the DV lottery. Those DV lottery winners pay US taxes while having no citizenship rights, so you have literally no idea what you're talking about.
- untog 14y agoVisa != citizenship And there are already plenty of routes for rich people to obtain visas, just by proving that they have a lot of money. These visas are for workers.
- drx 14y ago> Billions of dollars could be raised by turning these into entrepreneur visas or charging per visa (it's not like the US doesn't already do this, but the price is way too low) Every year a number of EB-5 visas go unclaimed (which cost around $550K per family).
- Daniel_Newby 14y ago
- ajays 14y agoOn the other hand: does the glut of tech workers drive down wages? If you strictly look at it from a supply/demand angle, one could argue that if these companies wanted more techies, they could just pay more. Being able to increase supply at will (i.e. import techies) will naturally drive down prices (i.e. wages). The same argument is made about illegal immigration: these immigrants fill low-end jobs that don't pay well; but their availability ensures that these jobs will never pay well. Please don't get me wrong: I'm not opposed to immigration or this bill.I'm just asking about the impact; I'm not taking sides, so no flames please.
- wtvanhest 14y agoI can't imagine why US engineers would support a bill like this from a benefit analysis perspective. It should be obvious that if you add engineers, prices will go down. I can completely understand supporting it for moral reasons however.
- prostoalex 14y ago1) It's not a whole lot different than H1-B and those haven't led to wage collapse. 2) Engineers who come into the US tend to start an insignificant number of new businesses, which, in turn, employ other engineers. 3) Countries that severely limit work visas have not turned into meccas of software development. 4) Companies will only increase pay up to a certain ceiling. At some point either the product economics don't make sense, or finding a dedicated development team in Romania/Poland/Ukraine is worth it even with communication overhead.
- moultano 14y agoI like working with colleagues from other countries. (I'm also marrying one.) I'd rather the best of the world do their great work inside of the US rather than outside.
- Daniel_Newby 14y ago> It should be obvious that if you add engineers, prices will go down. STEM is not a zero sum game. Adding personnel does not simply cut the pie into more pieces, it grows the pie. It's OK to get fewer dollars if those dollars can buy a self-driving car or a cure for Alzheimer's disease.
- seldo 14y agoAs a recent immigrant myself -- I got my green card last week, after a 5-year application process, and I'm one of the lucky ones -- I'm a huge fan of immigration reform. However, this is not the bill to do it. The 55,000 diversity visas are an essential part of how immigration should work: there should be more of them, not less. While we need more STEM educated immigrants, it should not be at the expense of other visa types.
- GuiA 14y agoI'm unfamiliar with diversity visas- who are they for, and what "good" are they supposed to provide?
- sharkweek 14y agolottery system for immigration, focused heavily on bringing in immigrants from countries that have lower immigration rates to the US -- http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Diversity_Immigrant_Visa http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Diversity_Immigrant_Visa
- seldo 14y agoThey are Visas available to anybody, for any reason, from any country. They are good because immigration is good. But let me explain a bit further. Most American visas are related to a specific job, or a family connection, or education. You can't just turn up and stay -- you have to have a reason, and a ton of documentation. But that's not how immigration has, historically, worked: the original American colonists and those that followed them through the 1700s and 1800s didn't arrive knowing where they'd live and what job they'd have. They arrived hoping to make a better life for their children, with no clear plan of how. That's what these visas are for. The situation is complicated slightly further because these are restricted to low-immigration-rate countries. Basically, there are a billion Indians and more than a billion Chinese: even a very small percentage of them applying for a visa lottery would mean that 99% of visas went to people from those countries. Therefore, to get immigrants from a broader range of countries, visas for people from countries that send a lot of applications every year are handled separately, under their own quotas. The remaining countries are all lumped together and given a group quota: these are the "diversity" visas. If you would like a more fundamental answer to why immigration is good, I'm happy to oblige, just ask :-)
- deepGem 14y agoI don't understand what's really wrong in diverting 55,000 visas from a random, unplanned allocation scheme (diversity) to a more metrics driven allocation scheme (education). How is this not 'true reform'?
- pyre 14y agoIs there a reason that we need to reallocate current visas? Why not just create 55K new STEM visas?
- wmil 14y agoThe only requirement for a diversity visa is a high school equivalent. Considering how poor the job market is for HS only graduates, limiting visas to people with marketable skills makes a lot of sense.
- eaurouge 14y agoMarketability should not be the only metric for valuing skills. How do you select the immigrant whose child will be the next Michael Phelps, or the next Einstein, or the next Pele?
- Evbn 14y agoYou select marketable immigrants with the resources to invest in education and training, like the people you named's parents.
- rhizome 14y agoPele grew up poor, Einstein's dad was a salesman, and Michael Phelps' parents are a retired cop and a principal, none of which would be eligible under the kinds of criteria being discussed here.
- icebraining 14y ago*Pelé. "Pele" means skin ;)
- zem 14y ago> White House announcement before congressional vote on STEM Jobs Act puts president in opposition to many of the Silicon Valley firms and executives who bankrolled his re-election campaign. it's sad that this was the point cnet chose to highlight as the subheading. bankrolling a politician's campaign should not create in him a sense of obligation.
- psychotik 14y agoAs a legal immigrant who has been in the country for 12 years and still waiting for a green card, I'm willing to accept that the administration will reject this bill if and only if it makes good on its promise for comprehensive reform. I also oppose the idea of cannibalizing the diversity visas - that seems to go against the spirit of the foundation of America's origins.
- drpgq 14y agoIEEE-USA is for this bill? I always thought they were in the camp that this drives down tech wages and promotes ageism.
- ck2 14y agoRemember the house likes to do the opposite of what he wants. Too bad he didn't want single payer.
- marknutter 14y agoI'm not sure it was a good idea to oppose this. It's essentially the republicans saying "We don't want to let any more people in the country, but of the people we are letting in, we prefer the highly educated". In a time when countries like China are graduating 50k engineers a year, you'd think being choosy about who you let into the country would make sense. And I don't see how signing this hurts the Democrats' long term plan for immigration reform. I assume that involves bringing more people into the country, so ok, bring more in later when the economy recovers. Not compromising on this bill setting a bad precedence for any compromise that may happen in the future.
- commandar 14y agoIt takes away the Republicans' opportunity to claim they already addressed immigration reform and that any further action is the President "going too far." The Republicans are between a rock and a hard place politically on immigration. Latinos are the fastest-growing demographic in the country, and Republican hostility toward immigration reform is starting to cost them in elections. e.g., Obama pummeled Romney among Latino voters in Florida by an over 2-to-1 margin. [1] The Republicans have essentially painted themselves into a corner on the issue and are in a no-win situation. If they continue to aggressively oppose immigration reform, it's going to hurt them with an increasingly-important demographic. If they concede and compromise, Obama and the Democrats get to claim themselves as the champions of immigration reform, which still hurts the Republicans, though to a lesser degree. Obama knows he has major leverage over the Republicans on this issue; it doesn't make political sense to make concessions they can paint as wins if it's not the reform he's actually after. [1] http://www.pewhispanic.org/2012/11/07/latino-voters-in-the-2012-election/ http://www.pewhispanic.org/2012/11/07/latino-voters-in-the-2...
- marknutter 14y agoThanks for the insight, I suppose it does sound like he made the right choice for his party. Interesting.
- commandar 14y ago
- eaurouge 14y agoThe diversity lottery is actually good immigration policy. Each year you take a sample of average or above average (applicants must have a high school education and no criminal history, and must pass some health tests as well; they must also show they will not be a burden to society once they get in) from countries around the world with historically low immigration rates to your country. Essentially these are candidates that have self-selected as being willing to start anew in a new country, working hard to improve their lives in the process. In return, your culture is enriched and your economy is boosted by a fresh set of ambitious, hard-working 1st-generation immigrants. Some of these immigrants may go on to become engineers, teachers, doctors, cab drivers, entrepreneurs, nurses etc. But they won't drain your social safety net, they will contribute to it. They're here to work, to make up for lost time, and to make a better future for their offspring. As immigration policies go, I think this is one of the better ones.
- enraged_camel 14y agoI think what is more important is that since this administration took over, rejection rates for skilled visa applications have skyrocketed. http://www.indianexpress.com/news/obama-warned-over-h1b-visa-denials/913370 http://www.indianexpress.com/news/obama-warned-over-h1b-visa... As someone who has had to respond to two RFEs so far - once for my initial H1B application and once for my green card application, I get the feeling that I am not wanted in this country. I have seriously contemplated moving back overseas more than once.
- antidoh 14y agoIf they're not going to let foreigners educated in US universities stay, then they shouldn't let foreigners take up space in universities. It makes no sense to make the seat available with no possibility of intellectual payback.