8 ms·
Telomerase – Mouse lifespan extended up to 24% with single treatment (May 2012)
- ceej 14y agoLots of misguided and misinformed comments on this topic. Learn the real science behind telomere research: http://www.sierrasci.com/?p=telomere_basics http://www.sierrasci.com/?p=telomere_basics Proof of concept: http://www.sierrasci.com/?p=proof_of_concept http://www.sierrasci.com/?p=proof_of_concept
- ommunist 14y agoWhat about the cats?
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- RandallBrown 14y agoAssuming no major side effects how long before something like this can be used in humans? What are the next steps even? Does the therapy used to treat the mice with these genes work with humans? What could the possible downsides of this be (other than things like overpopulation)?
- kenthorvath 14y agoBlasco also published in Rejuvenation Research last year about a dietary supplement that activates telomerase. So, that + this makes for some interesting reading. http://online.liebertpub.com/doi/abs/10.1089/rej.2010.1085 http://online.liebertpub.com/doi/abs/10.1089/rej.2010.1085
- dreamdu5t 14y agoMuch better than the science daily article. Thank you!
- kenthorvath 14y agoJust to clarify: The previous link I posted was not the one referenced in the Science Daily. That would be here: http://doi.wiley.com/10.1002/emmm.201200245 http://doi.wiley.com/10.1002/emmm.201200245 Unfortunately, all of these original articles are behind a paywall. Most of us here have some University access, I believe, but not all. Science Daily at leasts gets you the gist.
- pcl 14y agoNot I... It's been 13 years since I've had easy access to academic papers.
- ekianjo 14y agoI used to read Sciencedaily everyday but it's mostly unverified bullcrap reporting press release type of claims without criticism. They always report sensational discoveries but actually nothing every comes past the headlines in the actual world.
- woodchuck64 14y agoHmm.. $220 for 30 pills: http://ta-sciences.com/cgi-bin/xflow/shop.cgi?catid=0&username=pmiller http://ta-sciences.com/cgi-bin/xflow/shop.cgi?catid=0&us...
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- robbiep 14y ago1) Time until use in humans: 6 months to 50 years. Probably anyone's guess... Would suggest that the likely path once this research has been vetted would be to trial in medical conditions known to be associated with short telomeres such as Werner Syndrome, Ataxia Telangiectasia and others before being more widely adopted if this proved both safe and effective in humans. 2) The gene in question is conserved between humans and mice so yes, theoretically any therapy which induces telomerase in mice will do so in humans as well. [1] - 3) medically speaking the downsides are mostly 'unknown unknowns' - but some of the known unknowns are - what are the chances that the virus may integrate with the host genome? If this happens what are the chances it causes cancer? What are the risks of an immune reaction? What are the chances of mutation? It would seem that many of these risks are not borne out by the murine trial but it would remain to be seen. - I Should point out that (2) may convey the impression that they are upregulating the existing cellular gene to achieve this outcome: they are actually ntroducing one on the virus. In my opinion this is may be less effective than being able to eventually upregulate the gene in all cells as a virus is unlikely to get to all 10^13 (approximately, give or take an order of magnitude) cells in the human body. It could be that the 24% and 13% rates of lifespan increase (representing treatment at approximately middle age and old age respectively) may be due to the down-chain propagation of those cells that received the treatment and that more effectively delivering the virus or activating telomerase may result in better increases. However this is just my opinion and at the moment my University journal access is under maintenance so I can't read the paper [1] http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/sites/homologene/31141 http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/sites/homologene/31141
- grey413 14y agoConstant telomerase activation is one of the major steps in making cancer cells immortal and thus eventually metastatic. It's possible that controlled telomerase activation (via drugs or clever future gene therapies) might present a small enough increased cancer risk that it would be worth the increased health and longevity. Last I heard, gene therapies currently have fairly high risks involved with them (cancer, mostly).
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- reasonattlm 14y agoSo this one follows on from an earlier 2008 demonstration that claimed 50% life extension via much the same method. There is some annoyance from people in the know regarding that life span claim - it was apparently not very defensible based on the data to hand. Comments on the 2012 work here: http://www.fightaging.org/archives/2012/05/telomerase-gene-therapy-extends-life-eliminates-cancer-in-adult-mice.php http://www.fightaging.org/archives/2012/05/telomerase-gene-t... And here is the full paper: http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/emmm.201200245/full http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/emmm.201200245/fu...
- zone411 14y agoCaloric restriction also greatly extends life span in mice (http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/3958810 http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/3958810) but it hasn't translated into monkeys (http://www.nature.com/news/calorie-restriction-falters-in-the-long-run-1.11297 http://www.nature.com/news/calorie-restriction-falters-in-th...).
- Camillo 14y agoInteresting! I'm actually trying to eat a hypercaloric diet to increase my weight at the moment, and that's one less thing I have to worry about.
- pebb 14y agoAll the side effects are positives. The side effect we wants.
- freddealmeida 14y agoMy first thought was to my desktop mouse. lol. Pretty impressive discovery.
- qq66 14y agoMine too -- then I thought -- I've never had an optical mouse break on me, why would I need this? :)
- bluedanieru 14y agoThere has never been a better time to be a mouse.
- etherspin 14y ago24% more time spent being experimented on before your cancer ridden or organ failing demise !
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- michaelhoffman 14y agoThe telomeres are one of the cell's natural defenses against cancer. Telomerase makes it easier for a cell to divide uncontrollably, and most cancers have activated telomerases. Despite the claims that these mice don't have increased cancer, it would be wise to exercise much caution before pursuing this kind of treatment in a human.
- kenthorvath 14y agoThat's what clinical trials and FDA approval is for (at least in theory).
- michaelhoffman 14y agoIt would be wise to exercise much caution before pursuing this kind of treatment in a human, even as part of a clinical trial. I doubt an ethics committee would approve it as part of a clinical trial of a human anti-aging treatment.
- carbocation 14y ago> The telomeres are one of the cell's natural defenses against cancer. Telomerase makes it easier for a cell to divide uncontrollably, and most cancers have activated telomerases. These juxtaposed sentences come across as a bit contradictory. If telomeres are one of the cell's defenses against cancer, then telomerase activation should defend against cancer. Most cancers do activate telomerase, but telomerase is not an oncogene.[1] 1 = http://www.nature.com/onc/journal/v21/n4/abs/1205076a.html http://www.nature.com/onc/journal/v21/n4/abs/1205076a.html
- michaelhoffman 14y agoSpecifically I meant what many would regard as one of the telomeres' fundamental characteristics: their limited nature.
- carbocation 14y agoThat is true. It is also true that many regard their limited nature as a cancer risk. (Not being sarcastic; there is a divide here.) I think we can all agree that telomeres are critical for preventing non-homologous end joining where it shouldn't be occurring.
- xenophanes 14y agoWhat is the argument the mice were living a percentage longer instead of a roughly fixed amount of time longer?
- DigitalSea 14y ago"Want longer lasting life? try new LifeExtend from Bayer Pharmaceuticals coming soon to a pharmacy near you"
- andrewfelix 14y ago"...aging is not currently regarded as a disease, but researchers tend increasingly to view it as the common origin of conditions like insulin resistance or cardiovascular disease, whose incidence rises with age. In treating cell aging, we could prevent these diseases." Preventing disease by preventing age could be an unending justification for prolonging life. Are there other benefits associated with this treatment? The above explanation of the research doesn't sit well with me.
- tolmasky 14y agoAre you against preventing aging? (Just wanting to clarify what you meant by "doesn't sit well with me")
- andrewfelix 14y agoYes I mean ethically the idea of a single treatment extending life so dramatically doesn't sit well with me. I appreciate the need to improve quality of life in old age.
- tolmasky 14y agoSo is your concern that the quality of life would degrade as the rate it does now (so in other words, you don't want really miserable 110 year olds). Or, are you saying, even if we extended life and kept you feeling healthy for the same proportion as now, just longer (so things were now fine and dandy until, let's say, you're 80 and then slowly degrade to 110), you would still have a problem with it?
- andrewfelix 14y agoWhat the researchers seem to be suggesting is extending life for no specific reason, other than preventing the complications that are associated with aging that can and do eventually lead to death. So my issue is; there is no great societal benefit to just extending life for the sake of it, as opposed to say, making people more comfortable in their old age. IMO the world would not benefit from millions of people living until they're 130 years old.
- qiqing 14y agoThe rate at which therapies effective in mice translate to humans is surprisingly low. We've also cured cancer in mice around 200 times already.
- thisisnotmyname 14y agoInterfering with telomere activity is a critical step for cancer progression (see the halmarks of cancer, limitless reproductive potential), so this procedure essentially makes every cell in your body pre-cancerous. In my opinion, the most amazing part about this is that the way in which telomerase is delivered is via a retrovirus, typically a relative of HIV.
- carbocation 14y agoSince telomerase is not really an oncogene, I'm not sure that the notion of "pre-cancerous" that you're advocating has any meaning. By that token, nearly every cell is pre-cancerous, and in a fetus even more so.
- carbocation 14y agoI can nearly eliminate cholesterol in mice (well, they start out with very little to begin with) and my roommate can cure a Huntington's disease model in his lab mice. If media attention were given to every group to achieve something remarkable in mice, we would end up hearing about a lot of false starts. And false starts are a critical/inevitable part of science, so the only thing I'm really saying is that the media attention to this topic is most likely premature. Mice are a useful model, but they are different enough from humans that we should be cautious when interpreting mouse data in a broader context. Once repeated studies attacking the same problem from different angles in different institutions start to align, that's when my interest gets piqued. (Unless it's research within my field, in which case I feel better able to understand the strengths and limitations of early-stage studies.) I also admit that, to a certain extent, this is akin to a "middlebrow dismissal" (though I'm not trying to dismiss their work), and I'd love to hear from an expert in their specific domain.
- pasbesoin 14y agoOut of curiosity, any observation (casual or formal) of what happens to neural health when you eliminate cholesterol?
- nine_k 14y agoIsn't telomerase-based aging mechanism more or less the same in all mammals?
- awolf 14y ago> I can nearly eliminate cholesterol in mice "Cholesterol" is an organic compound that is essential for life. What exactly do you mean you can nearly eliminate it in mice?
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- carbocation 14y agoOf course you're right; I'm using colloquial shorthand. I'm referring to apolipoproteins bound to lipids and cholesterol (at which point we can call them lipoproteins). What I really am talking about is VLDL-cholesterol, LDL-cholesterol, HDL-cholesterol, and triglycerides. awolf's challenge is particularly relevant and on-point because extremely low levels of LDL-cholesterol from birth (hypobetalipoproteinemia or abetalipoproteinemia) is associated with neurological deficits. When caused by defective APOB, it is also associated with non-alcoholic fatty liver disease.
- kingkawn 14y agomost people's lifespans are currently not long enough for telomerase activity to make a meaningful impact on their cell longevity.
- duncan_bayne 14y agoEarly days, only mice so far, etc. etc. but this is pretty exciting. However ... One of my greatest fears is that my body will outlive my brain function. Hopefully research into various forms of senility will keep pace with longevity research so I don't wind up buff and spry at 120, completely unable to recognise my friends and loved ones. I have a family member in that state currently and it is heartbreaking to watch; I know that I'd prefer to die than live like that.
- lsc 14y agomeh, just in my lifetime, I've seen the outsourcing of memorization. Would you be able to do your job without a search engine? I wouldn't. Facial recognition (if you limit it to a limited number of faces) is already pretty good. I mean, yeah, my cognitive abilities degrading is also about the scariest thing I can think of, too, but eh, we are developing new crutches at a reasonable rate.
- duncan_bayne 14y agoHave you ever witnessed senile decay of that sort? I mean, said family member won't be helped by something / anything like Google or a notes app on a smartphone. She fails the three-word senility test, wherein you ask her to remember three simple words, distract her momentarily, and they're gone. Every. Single. Time. In addition, she thinks her dead husband is overseas checking out a property, doesn't recognise her grand-children, has no idea what year it is, and can't hold down a conversation. Outsourcing of memorisation is only helpful if you've sufficient marbles left to use the tools. This sort of problem needs a hardware fix - medical, cybernetic, you name it.
- 001sky 14y agoyes, this is a great point. raises the issue about experience: 10 years experience? or 1 yr experience repeated 10 times. Not the same thing at all. Do you really want to extend the latter ad-infinitim as 1 yr becomes->1 day->1hour repeated N times etc
- 14y ago
- someperson 14y ago[May 2012]
- hayksaakian 14y agoI thought this was about making my computer mouse last longer based on the title and context of hacker news.
- bitL 14y agoIt's good to be a mouse nowadays!
- bjhoops1 14y agoTreatments with "DNA-modified virus"? Looks like we're one step closer to the Zombie Apocalypse!
- stinky613 14y agoI really need to down at least one cup of coffee before I read HN in the morning; I was surprised by the headline because I couldn't imagine someone applying something to their computer mouse to increase its lifespan. {click the headline} OH! Those kind of mice. {facepalm} This is cool. It reminds me of hearing that tortoises don't suffer from deleterious aging[1]. I sure hope we can start expanding into space, moons, and planets before we have every John and Jane living multiple centuries. [1]http://io9.com/5618046/the-mystery-of-why-turtles-never-grow-old-+-and-how-we-can-learn-from-it http://io9.com/5618046/the-mystery-of-why-turtles-never-grow...