3 ms·
The US legal distinction is "substantial non-infringing use". If you are up to something and, like a search engine, happen to facilitate IP infringement, you're
by wpietri 14y ago
The US legal distinction is "substantial non-infringing use". If you are up to something and, like a search engine, happen to facilitate IP infringement, you're good. If there is no significant purpose to your service other than to help crime, it's criminal.
There are plenty of similar crimes: Conspiracy, harboring a known fugitive, material support for terrorism, receiving stolen goods, RICO. These can be misapplied, but the basic principle is reasonable: helping people commit crime can itself be criminal.
I don't think that's the problem here. I think the problem is with an IP system that's built on assumptions 100 years out of date.