4 ms·
That's maybe a bit of an unfair, out-of-balance comment. Google Gemini had it's own fails on the other side of the extreme. Both have corrected themselves. Don'
by gitaarik 4mo ago
That's maybe a bit of an unfair, out-of-balance comment. Google Gemini had it's own fails on the other side of the extreme. Both have corrected themselves. Don't keep coming up with old stuff.
- cherry_tree 4mo ago[flagged]
- gitaarik 4mo agoI'm not saying that, it's the opposite: Gemini generated too-woke images, like all images of people was like at least 50% colored, no matter what, even if you asked it to generate images of German World War 2 soldiers, it mostly generated black people in nazi uniforms.
- cherry_tree 4mo agoYour replies are non-sequitors to the discussion in this thread. Statement “I use grok to consume current events” Response “grok is not a reliable source for information, especially current events or politics” Your response “but Gemini generated images that right wingers didn’t like” Ok? Are those images the news? Is that a way to consume current events? Do you think I’m a proponent of people using LLMs to digest current events and am only against grok specifically? What exactly is your argument against mine (that grok shouldn’t be used to consume current events). Are you agreeing? Or are you suggesting that people should use grok for current events because Gemini produced images you didn’t like?
- gitaarik 4mo agoYou gave the argument that Grok isn't trustable because of their nazi fails. My argument was that you're maybe a bit biased, because similar issues have happened with other prominent companies. Both companies corrected themselves on the issues. I don't think your argument has much ground right now. Grok might be leaning into a certain direction, but you can say that about any AI or news station.
- deleted 4mo ago[deleted]
- deleted 4mo ago[deleted]
- Timon3 4mo agoAs someone stumbling across this thread: the idea that, in regards to bias, a real person might actually consider these two events in any way comparable is honestly leaving me stunned. I can't find the right words to describe how sickening it is to see Nazism being treated as just as banally acceptable as any other political direction.
- gitaarik 4mo agoYou're misreading. Nazism isn't being treated as acceptable, neither is wokeism. Both companies have apologized for these incidents, and have addressed the problems.
- Timon3 4mo agoNo, I'm understanding you perfectly well.
- Lerc 4mo agoYou understand their point of view and are just rejecting it? And commenting to express disagreement but not bothering to say why? I don't quite understand what's going on here?
- gitaarik 4mo agoYou said Nazism is being accepted like other political movements. But nobody (in this thread) ever said something like that.
- cherry_tree 4mo agoFrom my and seemingly others’ reading, you have equated Nazi and woke very directly in your comments. Do you feel you have you not?
- dang 4mo agoCan you please see https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48466218 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48466218 and respect the site guidelines when posting here, regardless of how wrong anyone else is or you feel they are? https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html