4 ms·

All things being equal, if a person works remotely, apparently they're more likely to trend reclusive. At the same time, a person working in an office has the

All things being equal, if a person works remotely, apparently they're more likely to trend reclusive. At the same time, a person working in an office has the illusion of social activity. Just because a person works in an office doesn't mean they're more well adjusted socially, or more active. Just because a person works remotely doesn't mean they're a recluse. Life requires effort and being engaged. Though as a remote worker myself, I do appreciate the tendency to not make an effort. However, when I do make an effort, the effort is easier and the reward greater than social activities that'd be available during an office job.

ubertaco 4mo ago
>All things being equal, if a person works remotely, apparently they're more likely to trend reclusive. The existence of families and housemates reveals this to be a false dichotomy: either you're spending in-office time with coworkers or you don't like being around any people, seems to be the claim.
- reg_dunlop 4mo ago
  Part of the study specifies remote workers living alone. So it appears the focus of the study excludes those fortunate enough to have family or housemates. But I do agree that the claim being made is the false dichotomy you point out
- j45 4mo ago
  Maybe the difference is what can happen passively going to a workplace, vs you get the life you design, learn, plan and execute on.
sublinear 4mo ago
> illusion of social activity This is so spot on. I would like to see stats for introverts who do not have mental health issues. Those living alone and working from home probably have the best outcomes across the board.
- reg_dunlop 4mo ago
  It would be interesting... My intention for using that specific language was less with the implied language of introvert/extrovert, and was more intended to point out how simply going to an office is not enough to qualify as "socialization". Compulsory attendance in exchange for financial gain isn't a great example of voluntary socialization....
j45 4mo ago
Healthy solitude is a gift for reflection. To an extreme, reclusion rids one of the input from living life around. Need input and reflection to be an upward spiral, otherwise input without reflection, or reflection without new input trends towards putting a person into a downward spiral.

ubertaco 4mo ago

>All things being equal, if a person works remotely, apparently they're more likely to trend reclusive. The existence of families and housemates reveals this to be a false dichotomy: either you're spending in-office time with coworkers or you don't like being around any people, seems to be the claim.

reg_dunlop 4mo ago
Part of the study specifies remote workers living alone. So it appears the focus of the study excludes those fortunate enough to have family or housemates. But I do agree that the claim being made is the false dichotomy you point out
j45 4mo ago
Maybe the difference is what can happen passively going to a workplace, vs you get the life you design, learn, plan and execute on.

sublinear 4mo ago

> illusion of social activity This is so spot on. I would like to see stats for introverts who do not have mental health issues. Those living alone and working from home probably have the best outcomes across the board.

reg_dunlop 4mo ago
It would be interesting... My intention for using that specific language was less with the implied language of introvert/extrovert, and was more intended to point out how simply going to an office is not enough to qualify as "socialization". Compulsory attendance in exchange for financial gain isn't a great example of voluntary socialization....

j45 4mo ago

Healthy solitude is a gift for reflection. To an extreme, reclusion rids one of the input from living life around. Need input and reflection to be an upward spiral, otherwise input without reflection, or reflection without new input trends towards putting a person into a downward spiral.