4 ms·
The train will never connect LA and SF. http://www.nytimes.com/2011/11/27/us/california-rail-project-advances-amid-cries-of-boondoggle.html?pagewanted=all
by temphn 14y ago
The train will never connect LA and SF.
http://www.nytimes.com/2011/11/27/us/california-rail-project-advances-amid-cries-of-boondoggle.html?pagewanted=all
The first phase would be a 130-mile stretch from
Bakersfield to just south of Chowchilla in central
California, at a cost of just over $6 billion; of that,
$2.6 billion would come from a $9 billion high-speed rail
bond passed by California voters in 2008, and $3.5 billion
from federal stimulus money.
...
The authority said it chose the relatively remote section
in the Central Valley as the first leg to be built, even
though few people there are looking to use a railroad, so
that construction could begin next year and meet deadlines
for using federal money. But critics suggest that the real
motivation was to get the spur in place, calculating that
future legislatures would not be able to abandon the
project before it reached major population centers.
“What they are hoping is that this will be to high-speed
rail what Vietnam was to foreign policy: that once you’re
in there, you have to get in deeper,” said Richard White, a
professor of history at Stanford University. “The most
logical outcome to me is we are going to have a white
elephant in the San Joaquin Valley.”
There is no plan on how to finance the project once the
bond and federal money is exhausted, beyond a hope of
private investment and public money during flusher times.
... Beyond that, several experts suggested that the train
would never attract the promised ridership, in no small
part because unlike, say, the Amtrak Northeast Corridor,
the bullet train would go into cities that do not have
particularly extensive public transit networks, forcing
people to rent cars once they arrived. Low ridership would
undercut the economic and environmental benefits that are
part of the argument for the project.
- melling 14y agoWhat will it connect after all $68 billion dollars is spent? Don't millions of people already fly between LA and SF? HSR is 50 year old technology that has been proven to work in several countrues. People in CA seem hell bent on building more roads. One of the main excuses why it won't work seems to be because no one thought it was important to build better mass transit. Btw, I was in SF last summer. BART and the trolley seemed sufficient.
- rprasad 14y agoThe point of the comment, I believe, was that it is unlikely that the railway will ever actually connect LA and Frisco b/c current levels of public funding are insufficient to build out the entire length. The full project will require significant private funding, which is unlikely. It the current stretch that is funded, i.e., Bakersfield, there is essentially no public transportation other than the occasional bus.
- melling 14y agoOf course it will all be built. People are just playing politics.