10 ms·
TV Shack owner strikes deal to avoid extradition
- rwmj 14y ago"Under the deal, the student will promise not to break copyright laws again in the knowledge that he will be liable for prosecution if he does." If that's literally what the deal says, I contend that is a completely impossible promise to keep.
- stuaxo 14y agoIt's a trap!
- barredo 14y ago> Mr O'Dwyer will travel to the US voluntarily in the next few weeks for the deal to be formally ratified, it is understood. IANAL but I don't think this will work as he and/or the UK justice thinks
- ma2rten 14y agoAs I understand it he made a deal with US, not UK, authorities.
- brador 14y agoI'm surprised his lawyer hasn't picked up on this. The second he hits US soil he's roasted.
- gadders 14y agoWouldn't this be just like a plea bargain?
- brador 14y agoOnce on US soil, with alleged crimes on US properties, he's under US law. If he has a signed deal that's something, if he's coming here with hope and a verbal agreement, as is enforced by honor in Europe, he's an idiot.
- hahainternet 14y agoUninformed comments like this belong on reddit, not here. I'll have a $100 bet with you he won't be roasted though. If you think you know more than his lawyer and the UK authorities in negotiating an international arrangement then it'll be easy money.
- rmc 14y agoI dunno, it would seem mightely stupid of the US authorities to drag him off in chains as soon as he's on US soil. If they do that, they might have a hell of a problem the next time they want to extradite anyone. Not to mention that you're now into "diplomatic incident" terroritory. I doubt the UK will sit by while a (white anglo) UK citizen is duped into going to the US and then imprisoned.
- martswite 14y agoI may be reading into this a bit more than needed, but, why the inclusion of the white anglo? Do you think the UK government would be more likely to let any other ethnic origin UK citizen, be duped, imprisoned and not be bothered?
- rmc 14y agoThat was more 'covering my ass', I'm sure there are examples of the UK handing some people over. The UK used to imprison without trial on UK soil some of it's UK citizens for terrorism crimes during it's recent civil war/unrest in Northern Ireland.
- martswite 14y agoYes but the situation here isn't a handing over is it really? This isn't/won't be an extradition. If the US were to arrest him on arrival when they have pretty much inferred he has nothing to fear, that would be something else. I would hope regardless of ethnic origin that the UK government would do everything in its power to have the citizen released. I'm not really clued up on the Northern Ireland conflicts, I do however find the idea of locking people up without trial and keeping them detained for long periods of time, barbaric, regardless of what they are accused of.
- rmc 14y agoI'm not really clued up on the Northern Ireland conflicts, I do however find the idea of locking people up without trial and keeping them detained for long periods of time, barbaric, regardless of what they are accused of. Things in Northern Ireland are much calmer now than they were (which is great!). There's still a lot more to do though. What's interesting is the things that didn't work but only made things worse. Interment without trial, made things worse, sending the army onto the streets made things worse. Car bombs by terrorists, or punishment shootings against 'informers', made things worse. This sort of violence makes things worse.
- DanBC 14y agoThe extradition had been sorted out in the UK end and he was going to be sent to the US anyway. So there's no need for the US to arrange some deal to "trick" him into going to the US. I'm curious why he has to go to actual America, and not just go to the embassy in London (which is US territory etc)?
- finnw 14y ago> the embassy in London (which is US territory etc)? It is not. http://integrity-legal.com/legal-blog/miscellaneous/laws-and-rules-regarding-extraterritoriality/ http://integrity-legal.com/legal-blog/miscellaneous/laws-and...
- DanBC 14y agoWow, thanks for that. I'm surprised more people don't know this. I'll stop spreading the misinformation.
- toyg 14y agoIt is still completely pointless. This is a completely unorthodox process anyway, so why can't he just agree to pay the money and be done with? Unless the answer is "because he shouldn't set a precedent": next time, the US government will still be able to say that all suspects were extradited in this sort of situation. Basically he's just being used to hack a statistic.
- glennsayers 14y ago"Mr O'Dwyer will travel to the US voluntarily in the next few weeks for the deal to be formally ratified, it is understood" Yeahhhhh he's not going to be coming back.
- InclinedPlane 14y agoYa know, I think it might be worth pointing out that the early business ventures of Woz and Jobs (of Apple computer) were in selling phone phreaking equipment. It certainly seems to me as though IP infringement of movies and music has become the most dangerous white collar crime in existence, even ahead of outright fraud and embezzlement in the multi-million or billion dollar range. To me that seems like a miscarriage of justice which could warp our society in negative ways.
- beedogs 14y agoI contend it already has. Locking arts and entertainment -- culture -- up for life plus 70 years (or 95 years for corporations) ensures it cannot be modified or built upon, as it had been for thousands of years prior to the mid-1970s, until it's completely irrelevant to the generations it's most influential upon.
- Osmium 14y ago> ... ensures it cannot be modified or built upon That's not entirely true. For example, it's easy to draw clear lines of inspiration between past and present movies. The line between homage and plagiarism has always been blurry. Regardless of laws, our culture will always be a "remix" culture, it can't exist any other way. Everything we do is derivative. But I agree, locking up arts in such a direct way is harmful. It creates unnatural roadblocks, and we'd be better off without them, but let's not get ahead of ourselves and claim that IP laws crush creativity.
- InclinedPlane 14y agoThe gulf between homage and derivative work is quite wide. Consider a few examples of famous derivative works: Baz Luhrmann's Romeo + Juliet, Alice in Wonderland, Apocalypse Now, Muppet Christmas Carol. Right now there are no less than 3 different ongoing adaptations of Sherlock Holmes (the movie series, the BBC series, and CBS's Elementary series). These are works that would be patently illegal if the source material were not in the public domain. This isn't just about "remix culture", it's about being able to adapt and interpret what's out there, fully and without restriction. Clearly there is value to allowing such artistic freedom once a work has grown sufficiently old. However, today that age has grown quite impractically long. A movie such as War of the Worlds (a 110+ year old book) can be made without seeking a licensing agreement, but movies such as The Hobbit (a 75 year old book), King Kong (79 years), The Chronicles of Narnia (62 years), Casino Royale (59 years), or The Dark Knight Rises (73 years) still require licensing. And the sad part is that even in the next 20 years when, say, the Superman IP will be pushing 100 years old and Mickey Mouse even older it seems likely that such things will still require licensing. The fact that the current IP laws have not utterly destroyed creativity or the productivity of creative industries is not a ringing endorsement. The fact is that they are stifling and they have been responsible for creating an industry which is too heavily controlled by a small group.
- RobAley 14y agoWhy is the US suddenly softening its stance in this case, both suggesting and approving such a "slap on the wrists"? They are currently trying to salvage what they can from UKs u-turn on their extradition deal (see the recent Gary Mckinnon stories). They don't want the extradition deal testing in court in the UK at the moment while they negotiate hard with the UK government, i.e. they don't want the UK courts to force the governments hand in any way before it forms its new policy. It would be nice if they had suddenly mellowed and realised that it wasn't the crime of the century, but alas it's not the case.
- mtgx 14y agoI guess they try to avoid cases with too much media attention. Look at the negative press that the Megaupload case is bringing to them.
- pja 14y agoYup. I also suspect that the US government itself doesn't give a fig for these copyright crimes, but is very concerned that any change to the law could prevent them extraditing UK-resident terrorist suspects to the US. A week before Gary McKinnon was suddenly found to be non medically fit to be extradited to the US & the announcement that the law was to be reformed several individuals charged with terrorist-related crimes were extradited to the US by the UK. I personally doubt the order of these events was a co-incidence.
- gadders 14y agoHe should have said he had "aspergers". TBH, I'd have been happier to see the McKinnon extradition go ahead than this one.
- experiment0 14y agoGah, this story always gets me riled up. I'm of the stance that linking to copyright material should most definitely NOT be breaking the law. It doesn't make sense on a number of levels (e.g. What position does this put any search engine in) but additionally he's not actually stolen the content, nor is he providing it, he is merely facilitating the access of it. Its equivalent to a sign on the street saying, "The staff have left this store, take what you want" and I really can't see how that could be construed to breaking the law. However I think there are other more technical issues that are not based on morality, such as the fact that the destination of a link can change without with the any indication. One minute a link could point to example.com and the next, a copyright infringing video on another video host. I do realise that in this case there was intent to provide a resource for those looking to illegally watch online content, but that is all it is, a resource. And the Brit inside me is also getting wound up by the US's involvement in this, the whole extradition thing is completely over the top and as much as I hate to sound like a conspiracy theorist exclaiming Hollywoods influence over the government, in this case I think its bang on. I completely agree with the sentiment expressed at the end, that "the US cannot be allowed to be the copyright cops of the world".
- blauwbilgorgel 14y agoI too got riled up about this linking to copyrighted material being a crime, certainly an extraditable one. You can't really compare a search engine to a site like TV-links. A search engine doesn't discriminate in what content it indexes. If a search engine would only link to copyright-infringing material, then that search engine can expect as much trouble as a site like TV-links. If a site mainly exists to facilitate copyright infringement, should it get a pass? If dealing drugs is against the law, what is directing people on the street to drug dealers? Things like changing link destinations are interesting from a technical point of view, but not all that relevant to this case IMO. If the site was a chatroulette for online links, this might come into play, but for TV links to have a changing link, in all likelihood it meant simply a broken link. Indeed, most of this boils down to intent. Pointing people on the street to where they can buy drugs or selling them pipes to facilitate drug use, to me, it isn't the same as dealing the drugs yourself. But I can totally see you can find yourself on the wrong side of the law, when you start facilitating illegal activity. Again, I agree that linking to content should always be possible, but I can understand where the law and entertainment industry is coming from.