5 ms·
for the same reason we want to know who wrote an article, a book, a movie, a song, a play, a journal paper, a painting, and on and on. why do you so many peopl
by toofy 4mo ago
for the same reason we want to know who wrote an article, a book, a movie, a song, a play, a journal paper, a painting, and on and on.
why do you so many people want to hide who the real author is?
we should be very weary of anyone claiming they’re the author of something when they’re absolutely not. if jon wrote a book and i take credit, that’s shady as hell.
- matheusmoreira 4mo agoGhostwriting is a thing.
- Barrin92 4mo agoyes because there's people who can't write but want to pretend that they can, just like the people who don't disclose they're using these tools. If you're the Gwyneth Paltrow of programming you're not making a great case for yourself, and I'd like to know before touching any of the software.
- matheusmoreira 4mo agoI don't know, am I? Why don't you check out my work and decide for yourself? Better than forming prejudiced opinions about others.
- Barrin92 4mo ago>Why don't you check out my work and decide for yourself? because no person can read every line of code written in software they use, or track every commit made to a project. Integrity and authorship matters. If a person lies or obfuscates the origin of what they produce, an article, software, what have you they're doing it for a reason, otherwise they would be honest. That's not prejudice, that's recognizing deceit. And you don't eat fruit from a rotten tree.
- matheusmoreira 4mo ago> because no person can read every line of code written in software they use, or track every commit made to a project Ask Claude to do it for you. > they're doing it for a reason And you concluded that the reason was they were pretenders who can't hack it. That's your prejudice. Not interested in helping you categorize me, thanks.
- kelnos 4mo agoThat's fine; don't contribute to projects that ask for proper attribution, then, and I suppose everyone will be happy.
- matheusmoreira 4mo agoAs I said, attribution is polite. If you're going to openly pre-judge and disrespect people on that basis though, the calculus changes.
- kelnos 4mo agoYes, and I respect ghostwritten work less than I do a work with a disclosed true author. Same would be true of unattributed AI-generated code.