3 ms·
There's no such thing as a cross-platform GUI layer that doesn't suck. Qt comes the closest, and it has all sorts of platform-specific hacks in it, some even v
by bitwize 14y ago
There's no such thing as a cross-platform GUI layer that doesn't suck.
Qt comes the closest, and it has all sorts of platform-specific hacks in it, some even visible at the API level.
If you're going to be writing something that's used as frequently and intensively as an IDE, then it had BETTER conform to the user interface guidelines of whatever OS it's running on. Those differ on Windows or Mac, and Linux doesn't really have any.
- aroman 14y agoI definitely agree with your thoughts on this, but I guess I wanted to add that Linux most definitely _does_ have human interface guidelines -- they're just not the same for every flavor of Linux under the sun. Granted a lot of Linux apps tend to be "cross-environment", or just cross-platform in general, so it's less obvious than on Mac, for example. But GNOME definitely has them[1], and newer projects which have dedicated themselves to a really solid HIG are gaining a lot of traction[2]. [1] http://developer.gnome.org/hig-book/stable/ http://developer.gnome.org/hig-book/stable/ [2] http://elementaryos.org/docs/human-interface-guidelines http://elementaryos.org/docs/human-interface-guidelines I guess the issue comes down to more people needing to _care_ about them :)
- Derbasti 14y agoI used to think so, too. But then, IDEs and developers are kind of special. IDEs are mostly just big rectangles full of text, which are eminently platform independant. Developers are special in that that we are very used to staring at terminals and logs, and are very accustomed to work with colored but unformatted text. Also, workflows tend to be very similar, across platforms and environments. So that leaves us with not much reason for platform dependance, and thus Eclipse, Emacs/Vim/etc., and terminals. Even Visual Studio sports many things, but a native look is not among them. I guess XCode is the only really platform-dependant IDE I know. All the others could just as well run on different platforms or even do so. So, umm, I respectfully disagree.