3 ms·
Yeah, maaaaaaaaan. And weed cures all forms of cancer -- that's why it's illegal. If Big Pharma wanted to push dangerous or ineffective drugs on the public, t
by bitwize 14y ago
Yeah, maaaaaaaaan.
And weed cures all forms of cancer -- that's why it's illegal.
If Big Pharma wanted to push dangerous or ineffective drugs on the public, there are far easier and cheaper ways to go about it than coming up with elaborate double-blind, randomized, placebo-controlled testing protocols. See: Vioxx.
Experiments using illegal drugs are always problematic, because researchers tend to be advocates for legalization and may be biased by their emotional investment.
But MAPS, a pro-psychedelics organization, is neutral. Shyeah -- about as neutral as High Times.
This person is expressing sincere doubt -- probably because she's seen enough medical research to know that drugs that seem like miracle cures in pilot studies often pan out to be not so miraculous when tested in broader studies with larger cohorts -- and that's true whether the drug in question is politically controversial (like MDMA, LSD, or marijuana) or not.
I say this as one who supports drug legalization and wants to see further research conducted with MDMA. Until the results of larger studies come in, there's still room for doubt here.
- Alex3917 14y ago"If Big Pharma wanted to push dangerous or ineffective drugs on the public, there are far easier and cheaper ways to go about it than coming up with elaborate double-blind, randomized, placebo-controlled testing protocols." That's demonstrably false. There are dozens of books on the topic, many of which I link to here: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4807436 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4807436 "Until the results of larger studies come in, there's still room for doubt here." No question there's room for doubt. My issue isn't with the fact that the author doubts that MDMA will be effective, which it may well not be, but rather that she is being intellectually dishonest in her arguments.
- dmix 14y agoThere's also been plenty of books showing how big pharma is deeply connected to regulators and health agencies which help them get meds through. More commonly they mislabel existing meds for conditions they don't really help with (or have dangerous side effects) - without significant consequences. Fortunately, the economic disincentive is getting larger each year: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_largest_pharmaceutical_settlements http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_largest_pharmaceutical_...
- bitwize 14y agoThat's demonstrably false. You haven't demonstrated it false; I can demonstrate it true. she is being intellectually dishonest in her arguments. Or she is just unaware of the scope of MDMA reesearch conducted thus far. I doubt this is her specialty.
- SilasX 14y ago>If Big Pharma wanted to push dangerous or ineffective drugs on the public, there are far easier and cheaper ways to go about it than coming up with elaborate double-blind, randomized, placebo-controlled testing protocols. See: Vioxx. ??? Vioxx was not at all cheap or easy to bring to market, nor was it ineffective. Rather, it was a case where a drug was tremendously beneficial to most users but deadly for a small subset. Even after its withdrawal from the market, US and Canadian government panels have voted in favor of bringing it back based on cost-benefit analysis! http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vioxx#Withdrawal http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vioxx#Withdrawal I don't think it's possible to have a worse example of the drug company behavior you mentioned. Why not point to the days of phony, deadly cures being pushed on a naive population? Vioxx had actual research and efficacy behind it, and may actually merit coming back on the market.
- bitwize 14y agoMerck had a sweetheart deal with Elsevier to publish a vanity journal which passed off marketing copy for Vioxx as "research". Why not point to the days of phony, deadly cures being pushed on a naive population? That's still going on, except these days the pushers of phony, deadly cures sound a lot like Alex3917. Hint: look for accusations of medical researchers being "shills of big pharma". Vioxx gives us a handy, recent example of big pharma actually behaving badly,and they had to undermine science to do it. Just like the peddlers of unproven "alternative cures" -- and quite unlike, and to the dismay of, the medical research community.
- SilasX 14y agoIf it's being recommended for re-introduction even knowing what actually happened, and is responsible for the health of the overwhelming majority of those who took it, I don't think that counts as an example of a case where you "needed" to corrupt journals to get it approved.