4 ms·
Both the article and the comments here and on the blog suffer from the mistake of being binary. You can get in trouble for copyright violation for doing anythi
by VLM 14y ago
Both the article and the comments here and on the blog suffer from the mistake of being binary.
You can get in trouble for copyright violation for doing anything. Reality and law have nothing to do with it. Its a common techie misconception that there exists a root password or exploit to the law. Law is an engineering puzzle with factors of safety based on human judgement, not a mathematical puzzle or proof.
What the author wrote is basically true, from the perspective of what you need to do at the level where you want a typical judge to laugh an accusation out of his court. In strict contrast, most of the comments here and on the the blog are "if you wish really hard, this is the way I'd like it to be" or at best "at least some people after spending tens of thousands on legal defense won at least one case trying this" and even more hilarious "Sure its illegal, but most people get away with it".
There are several analogies with online discussion of speeding tickets and cars.