3 ms·

I don't want random apps to paste potentially dangerous things into other apps. Its understandable. Imagine a banking app, and for example an IBAN field.

notlive 4mo ago
I would like the option to allow the behaviour selectively
- DelightOne 4mo ago
  That's what install outside of the App Store is for. On your own risk-
kuboble 4mo ago
Them you are free to not install them? Why ban them outright? I'm using https://github.com/cjpais/Handy https://github.com/cjpais/Handy whichseems to be doing exactly what this app does, and has a very similar background story (author couldn't type die to injury).
- amazingamazing 4mo ago
  To their defense you cannot rollback apps, so if you did install and only an update had this function, you are out of luck
  - applfanboysbgon 4mo ago
    "In their defense, the OS is even more insane with mandatory forced application updates that you have no control of". I hope I won't ever happen to have you representing me as a defense attourney!
- mrweasel 4mo ago
  In this case it feels like it's a feature that the operating system should be providing or something that could be marked as an accessibility tool, which would allow it to use that API. The problem from Apples perspective could be that there is a ton of tools that require access to the accessibility API because they want to do stuff that Apple have deemed a security risk and the only way to do it is by abusing the API. Some of these are also because macOS simply lacks certain APIs. I think Apple overreacting due to previous API misuse by other apps.
  - RZelaya 4mo ago
    [dead]
- SyneRyder 4mo ago
  Handy is excellent and cross platform, and really elegant. They've got a direct website here which might be easier to navigate than the Github repo: https://handy.computer/ https://handy.computer/
  - RZelaya 4mo ago
    Handy looks great. More tools in this space is a good thing for people who need them.
RZelaya 4mo ago
I see, that's a really fair point. And I can understand that banking field example. So I can see why they're guarding against it. My disagreement was less with the rule itself and whether Whisperpad's specific use case for users with mobility needs falls on the right side of it.
deleted 4mo ago
[deleted]
boxed 4mo ago
Pasting doesn't seem very unsafe. Especially not when the app can't know what it's pasting into.

notlive 4mo ago

I would like the option to allow the behaviour selectively

DelightOne 4mo ago
That's what install outside of the App Store is for. On your own risk-

kuboble 4mo ago

Them you are free to not install them? Why ban them outright? I'm using https://github.com/cjpais/Handy https://github.com/cjpais/Handy whichseems to be doing exactly what this app does, and has a very similar background story (author couldn't type die to injury).

amazingamazing 4mo ago
To their defense you cannot rollback apps, so if you did install and only an update had this function, you are out of luck
- applfanboysbgon 4mo ago
  "In their defense, the OS is even more insane with mandatory forced application updates that you have no control of". I hope I won't ever happen to have you representing me as a defense attourney!
mrweasel 4mo ago
In this case it feels like it's a feature that the operating system should be providing or something that could be marked as an accessibility tool, which would allow it to use that API. The problem from Apples perspective could be that there is a ton of tools that require access to the accessibility API because they want to do stuff that Apple have deemed a security risk and the only way to do it is by abusing the API. Some of these are also because macOS simply lacks certain APIs. I think Apple overreacting due to previous API misuse by other apps.
- RZelaya 4mo ago
  [dead]
SyneRyder 4mo ago
Handy is excellent and cross platform, and really elegant. They've got a direct website here which might be easier to navigate than the Github repo: https://handy.computer/ https://handy.computer/
- RZelaya 4mo ago
  Handy looks great. More tools in this space is a good thing for people who need them.

RZelaya 4mo ago

I see, that's a really fair point. And I can understand that banking field example. So I can see why they're guarding against it. My disagreement was less with the rule itself and whether Whisperpad's specific use case for users with mobility needs falls on the right side of it.

deleted 4mo ago

[deleted]

boxed 4mo ago

Pasting doesn't seem very unsafe. Especially not when the app can't know what it's pasting into.