4 ms·
I think he's being clear. He wrote: "So let’s set the record straight. You cannot legally sample music without clearance. It begins and ends there. If someone
by chris_wot 14y ago
I think he's being clear. He wrote:
"So let’s set the record straight. You cannot legally sample music without clearance. It begins and ends there. If someone were to take a tiny clip of one of my songs, pitch it down to 10% speed, reverse it, and slam 8 minutes of echo on it, I could sue their pants off (not that I would, or even be able to detect such a thing)."
He's saying this under all circumstances. Note that you can create works for commercial purposes for teaching. If course, the statute states that this will be taken into consideration.
Now don't get me wrong, fair use is a nebulous thing. You'll most likely not fall under fair use provisions in most circumstances. It's not always clear what a court will decide, so I agree - if you sample, best to get permission! But making sweeping statements that something is not and will never be covered under fair use is wrong.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- mmcnickle 14y agoAs much as I dislike arguing semantics, the resolution of this comes down to the definition of "sample". For what it's worth, I read it to mean for the use in commercial works.
- chris_wot 14y agoAnd yet it can still be valid to have a sample in a commercial work under fair use.