4 ms·
Isn't that nice. This isn't the most concerning aspect about the use of drones though. The concerning part is the extension of the definition of "battlefield".
by InclinedPlane 14y ago
Isn't that nice. This isn't the most concerning aspect about the use of drones though. The concerning part is the extension of the definition of "battlefield".
Currently the definition of what is a battlefield is little different than "wherever we decide to put a drone". However, this leaves a lot to be desired from a rules-of-war and civil liberties perspective. The thought that merely visiting some city in the developing world and hanging around with the wrong folks could result in you dying in a battlefield via remote drone attack is more than a little disturbing, especially when compared against all of the normal heuristics a sensible human with good-intentions would typically use to avoid being involved in a war and especially being killed in battle.
Certainly there are risks and downsides to operating under rules-of-war which are too limiting or too strict but the solution is not to throw everything out and create effectively unlimited power with almost no safeguards, limitations, or accountability. And that is the road we seem to be heading down. As history has shown, power without accountability and limitations is never a good idea and will inevitably lead to intentional abuse.
- chimeracoder 14y ago> hanging around with the wrong folks could result in you dying in a battlefield via remote drone attack is more than a little disturbing Being a minor (16 years old) and a US citizen (born in Denver) won't protect you from "having the wrong father", as Abdulrahman_al-Aulaqi can tell you[1]. It's not reassuring at all to me to know that a human, rather than a robot, is making the decision, as long as I don't know (or trust) the criteria that that human is using. [1] (Except he can't, because he was assassinated last year, far from any "battlefield" - or even any country that the US is at war with, for that matter.)
- mousa 14y ago"and a US citizen (born in Denver) " I've never understood the emphasis on this point. You're either for or against drone attacks on presumed terrorists, I can't understand how US citizenship plays any role in it. If his father was involved in terrorism and you think drone strikes are OK, why would you have extra sympathy for him because he's a US citizen? I don't think the US citizen aspect is worth mentioning, in fact I think it just makes people who are against drones seem a little unhinged. By the way I am against the use of drones (on Americans or otherwise).
- chimeracoder 14y ago> If his father was involved in terrorism and you think drone strikes are OK, why would you have extra sympathy for him because he's a US citizen? As of April 2010, the open, stated objective of the CIA was to kill Aulaqi's father (and others on President Obama's "hit list") and, if and only if he could not be killed, to arrest him, charge him formally, and bring him to trial. In other words, "if we can kill him, we don't have to prove he was actually guilty." I don't support the drone strikes against non-US citizens, but the idea that a single executive can issue capital punishment on a US citizen[1] without a trial is downright unnerving. Imagine if police officers wielded that same level of power - it's no different. [1] The US Constitution does not provide the same levels of protection to non-Citizens, which is why drone-strikes on foreigners is still disgusting but not as terrifying (from the perspective of a US citizen).
- stcredzero 14y ago> Imagine if police officers wielded that same level of power - it's no different. Seems to me that there are plenty of police officers who try through the claim of self defense.
- joeyo 14y ago>[1] The US Constitution does not provide the same levels of > protection to non-Citizens, which is why drone-strikes on > foreigners is still disgusting but not as terrifying (from > the perspective of a US citizen). I hear this asserted frequently but it is simply not the case. There are a very few places where the citizenship requirement is explicitly stated (e.g. voting or holding public office), but generically the US Constitution refers to "persons" not citizens. For a scholarly article on this topic, see: http://scholarship.law.georgetown.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1302&context=facpub http://scholarship.law.georgetown.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?ar...
- jfoutz 14y agoCitizens are entitled to due process. There are probably a bunch of other reasons i'm overlooking, but I get kind of uptight about the government ignoring the bill of rights.
- anigbrowl 14y agoWhen you go to another country and openly wage war upon the US, you make yourself a military target. You don't get to wrap yourself in the constitution and enjoy all the procedural protections of the criminal justice system under such circumstances. If Anwar al -Awlaki had felt his life was in danger, he could have just turned himself in to a US consulate and asked for his legal rights. As for his son, I blame the father for taking him with him to live in an Al-Qaeda stronghold, and effectively using him as a human shield.
- b6 14y ago> When you go to another country and openly wage war upon the US, you make yourself a military target. His main activity was recording videos in which he expressed his ideas. If he was thought to have committed other crimes, he had the right to be tried for them. > As for his son, I blame the father for taking him with him to live in an Al-Qaeda stronghold That didn't happen. IIRC, he was killed at a dinner party. We're not even certain who it was the US was trying to kill during that strike.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- tzs 14y agoThe drone strike that killed the kid was targeting Ibrahim al-Banna (and it succeeded in killing him). They almost certainly did not expect that the kid would be there, considering that he lived over 100 miles away far from where that drone struck.
- freshhawk 14y agoBut you don't have to openly do anything. Military aged males in specific areas are presumed militants. Where those areas are is classified. > If Anwar al -Awlaki had felt his life was in danger, he could have just turned himself in to a US consulate and asked for his legal rights Hahahahaha, that's a good one.
- anigbrowl 14y ago