4 ms·
Crossposting my comment from the blog post here, because the Arduino servers are apparently under heavy load, and most people will TLDR the post and just look a
by jmole 14y ago
Crossposting my comment from the blog post here, because the Arduino servers are apparently under heavy load, and most people will TLDR the post and just look at the comments here.
======
Hi All,
I recently launched a Kickstarter project as well, that ended about a month and a half ago: http://www.kickstarter.com/projects/18182218/freesoc-and-freesoc-mini http://www.kickstarter.com/projects/18182218/freesoc-and-fre...
Dimitri, the creator of the smARtDUINO project got in touch with me a few weeks ago to collaborate on creating a smARtBUS adaptor for our platform.
We’ve exchanged over 40 emails since then, and my impression is that he’s an earnest, upstanding man, who really cares a lot about the electronics community and making it easier and less expensive for people to do creative things.
We had a discussion about Kickstarter in particular, and one of the things he mentioned to me in our conversation was that he felt his campaign placed too much emphasis on the “Arduinoness” of the project, and not enough emphasis on the true innovation, which is the smARtBUS interconnect system.
We discussed the perils of successfully marketing a Kickstarter project, and said in retrospect, “If we communicate better the project, I have no idea were we can be now that it should be clear this is not just another Arduino.” (this was about a week ago, near the end of his campaign.)
I think if you can honestly blame him for anything, it’s not effectively conveying the message of the product in an concise way. If his workers were indeed manufacturing Arduino in Italy, there’s nothing wrong with claiming it. I’ll admit that the claim might look deceptively grand at first glance, but my intuition tells me this has more to do with Dimitri’s English ability, rather than a malevolent attempt at hijacking the Arduino brand.
- asmithmd1 14y agoThe issue is the owner of the trademark "arduino" wants the wording changed on the project to avoid confusion. If this is a simple misunderstanding why is the project owner being unresponsive? I am sure the project owner's contact info is up to date with Kickstarter since he is expecting a +$150k wire transfer from them.
- jmole 14y agoHe's been very responsive. Look at the blog post comments. Also, to clear up a misconception, Kickstarter doesn't pay the project creators, Amazon does. It pays the creator individually for each backer, and then money is transferred to Kickstarter from the Creator's payment account. So the individual backers pay the Creator, the Creator pays Kickstarter. But it all happens automatically.
- kfury 14y agoUnresponsive? Whatnow? He has more comments on the blog post than the post's author! He's asked repeatedly for the author to email him directly, allowing him to release the invoices for the orders the post author claims are nonexistent, but hasn't heard anything from him outside of the public blog post.
- barabba 14y agoTurns out the Arduino guys were well aware of the issue a month ago: http://smartduino.com/arduinotmtrademark-intimated-us-to-close-the-domain-and-cancel-our-product/ http://smartduino.com/arduinotmtrademark-intimated-us-to-clo.... So I guess the unresponsiveness is on their side...