> [...] instead encourage a wealth tax on hoarding that directly transfers charity from the wealthiest to the poorest (tithe or zakaat). Hoarding of what? Com

> [...] instead encourage a wealth tax on hoarding that directly transfers charity from the wealthiest to the poorest (tithe or zakaat). Hoarding of what? Commodities? Should I be taxed for hoarding firewood before winter? Money? Only poor people hoard money. The wealthy invest it.