4 ms·
Maybe the notion of "total motherhood" is the problem? If those mums wouldn't feel the need to "hover" above their kids every second, perhaps they would be less
by yummyfajitas 14y ago
Maybe the notion of "total motherhood" is the problem? If those mums wouldn't feel the need to "hover" above their kids every second, perhaps they would be less stressed out?
This is the thesis of Bryan Caplan.
He has gathered a lot of evidence (mainly from twin studies) suggesting that the specific details of how you raise your kids don't matter much [1] - your kids will turn out to be the average of their parents + regression to the mean.
I.e., by age 25, the children of Amy Chua and slacker dad will turn out the same, regardless of whether Chua or slacker gets their way.
WSJ article: http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052748704289504575313201221533826.html http://online.wsj.com/article/SB1000142405274870428950457531...
Book: http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/0465028616/ref=as_li_ss_tl?ie=UTF8&camp=1789&creative=390957&creativeASIN=0465028616&linkCode=as2&tag=christuc-20 http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/0465028616/ref=as_li_ss_tl?...
[1] Within the bounds of non-abusive middle class first-world parents. As one example, if both parents are religious, the child is likely to be religious. The only factor the parents have significant influence over is Lutheran vs Catholic.
- Tichy 14y agoI've heard about that, even own the book but didn't read very far yet. I remain skeptic. Maybe it holds for "standard parenting techniques", but I am more interested in for example the approach of László Polgár http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/L%C3%A1szl%C3%B3_Polg%C3%A1r http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/L%C3%A1szl%C3%B3_Polg%C3%A1r He raised 3 kids to become chess grandmasters - and he announced he would do that before they were born. I don't think he was abusive either. Somehow nobody really wants to talk about that, it is weird. Perhaps it scares people to think that they might be responsible for not making their kids brilliant. And the elite might have an interest in not letting the secret out - somebody has to do the slavery jobs in society, after all. Yeah it is a bit paranoid, but I have become a bit cynical about the setup of our society. Actually it doesn't even have to be an elite trying to hold us down, I think research has shown that people are most happy if other people are not better off than they are, so people are always trying to hold each other down. Of course I wouldn't condone methods like the tiger mum (I think she is basically a criminal), but I don't think Polgar was abusive, for example. I guess if you can influence if your kid is Lutheran or Catholic, there are also other things that might have a bigger impact (even Catholic vs Lutheran might make a big difference, I don't really know? What with different work ethics?). Lutheran vs Catholic or "technical vs liberal arts" and so on? Edit: I discovered Polgar through the book "Bounce" which also talks about other cases for deliberately creating gifted kids http://www.amazon.de/Bounce-myth-talent-power-practice/dp/0007350546/ref=sr_1_3?ie=UTF8&qid=1353940584&sr=8-3 http://www.amazon.de/Bounce-myth-talent-power-practice/dp/00...
- yummyfajitas 14y agoCaplan's empirical results certainly don't rule out effects from extremely non-standard (e.g., Polgar) parenting techniques. Then again, the anecdotal results of the Polgar family are also quite consistent with his thesis. Laszlo Polgar and his wife are both obsessively ambitious and quite intelligent, and Laszlo even obsesses about chess. Caplan's thesis suggests that if raised by others, the Polgar girls might merely have picked up poker or math rather than chess. If I recall Caplan's book correctly, "technical vs liberal arts" is suggested by twin studies to be primarily genetically determined. The separately raised twin of a civil engineer is far more likely to be an electrical engineer than to work in HR, for example. As for Lutheran vs Catholic, it's certainly extremely important - if your kids get it wrong, they will be tortured in hell forever.
- Tichy 14y agoThe interesting thing about Polgar is that he announced he would raise gifted kids before he even had them - he didn't even have a wife then, instead he looked for a wife willing to do the experiment. He wasn't obsessed about chess, he just picked it because it was easy to measure success. He then studied it himself so that he could teach his kids. Sure, it is still an anecdote, but he repeated it three times with his children. It seems incredibly lucky if all of his children just happened to be super-gifted and would have become prodigies in any discipline just because of their genes, and him knowing they would be like that before they were born.
- 14y ago
- nvarsj 14y agoI've never been comfortable w/ Caplan's ideas. Maybe the average stays consistent, but outliers differ based on parenting techniques. Surely quality of education plays a large role. He also seems to ignore the large body of evidence which shows socioeconomic background plays a big role in kids' success. My personal opinion is that Caplan's book presents a minority view based on some limited statistics. Strangely it seems to show up a lot on HN.
- yummyfajitas 14y agoSurely quality of education plays a large role. Why are you so sure of this? Most of the evidence I've seen suggests variation in education quality accounts for very little of the variation in educational outcomes - student race is the biggest predictor and student income is a distant second. This applies internationally as well as intranationally. He also seems to ignore the large body of evidence which shows socioeconomic background plays a big role in kids' success. He explicitly acknowledges his data applies primarily to children raised in middle class first world nations. He doesn't ignore socioeconomic background, holds it constant and lets other factors vary. If you have statistics which contradict Caplan, I'd love to see them.
- Tichy 14y agoIf he holds socioeconomic status constant, how can he arrive at student income being a strong predictor? Doesn't equal socioeconomic status kind imply equal "student income"? Also I wonder how quality of education is being measured?
- barry-cotter 14y agoThe social status of people on exactly the same income can differ markedly. My first idea on how I'd disentangle SES effects from income would be parental highest degree. I imagine the average MBA is smarter than the average BA but dumber than the average PhD. And JDs and MDs will make more than any of them. If you restrict your sample to those with over 100K in annual income there will still be some people who are self employed trades people even. And the way I'd bet would be that the children of (Educational attainment group X) have more in common with their counterparts with poorer parents than with the group (has rich parents). Read Bryan's book, read Judith Rich Harris' “The Nurture Assumption”, read Amy Chua's book. Read the literature on heritability and mutability of personality traits and intelligence. It's all left me thinking that if I'm going to go for more aggro I'll just go for another child or earning more money. And Amy Chua really, really did not beat the soul out of either of her daughters. The space of non abusive First World middle class parenting styles encompasses her easily.