4 ms·
The DRM-free is nice, and they get some large amount of points for doing so. But ads in hacker news, masquerading as an article? Can we keep commercials out pl
by belorn 14y ago
The DRM-free is nice, and they get some large amount of points for doing so.
But ads in hacker news, masquerading as an article? Can we keep commercials out please?
(interesting to see that people are not contesting that the link/title is an actually an ad, but that people are arguing that ads should exist because they are useful. The role and appropriateness of ads alongside other content looks to be a controversial subject.)
- barking 14y agoStill though, I'd probably not have heard about it otherwise
- belorn 14y agoThats what banners/newsletters and ads in TV and radio, and in magazines, and movies, and at ball games... and on buses and milk cartons and t-shirts, and bananas and written on the sky are for. But not in news aggregators, no siree.
- mhurron 14y agoAbsolutely, promoting other useful products to the community is not in any way what HN is about. You should be here pushing your own startup, useful or not, or reading some pointless blog of someone just because they started yet another picture sharing service that will be dead tomorrow, or fawning over whomever the latest superstar is. But one day sales on useful information that would otherwise be missed by many users here? Oh no, there's a group think to be maintained.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- melling 14y agoWho thought it was an article? Some sort of O'Reilly coupon gets posted a couple times a year. In fact, deeply discounted tech books from most publishers are welcome. What you're suppose to do here is recommend great books on the list.
- belorn 14y agoAre you saying that the goal of hacker news is to post commercial ads with coupons for people to see? Really? that's the goal of this site? I wouldn't mind an article which talked about different books and in that context, which just happened to mentioned that there was a sale going on with 50% off. That would give room of discussion. But this is just a text banner ad with a open comment field. If it had been a real banner, positioned at the right side of the screen, I would not complain as it would be clear that its an ad and not ordinary content. I would even consider a small disclaimer tag in the title ([hacker news commercial] to be fair, but to actually be listed as any other news article?
- boundlessdreamz 14y agoYou are taking this way too seriously. Posts like this are rare. Also very useful. I have bought ebooks before in sales which I came to know via HN. As the GP said the best part was the discussion by people about the books they are buying and why. If you don't like this post, flag it.
- DanBC 14y ago> Are you saying that the goal of hacker news is to post commercial ads Are you suggesting that O'Reilly paid to have this link posted to HN? That's not correct. They didn't. Someone saw the offer, knew that many people on HN would find it useful, and posted it. It's valid to not like it, and to ignore it or flag it, but don't dislike it for something that didn't happen.
- belorn 14y agoI dont think they paied for it, and I dont dislike O'Reilly. They didnt do anything here beyond having a sale and selling non-drm products. Like I initially said, they get major points for this. I only pointed out that this is an ad promoting a sale. No one seams to contest that. What people seems to have an issue with is the claim that ads should not sit alongside other articles. It would be interesting to hear why having a ad promoting a sale posted in a news aggregate is a good thing, or why in this case we should have an exception that sites like amazon or newsegg does not deserve. After all, they too have done 1 day's sales, some very interesting for hackers. Thus, I am failing to find an attribute that this ad differ from all other ads. Does anyone has an insight to what that attribute is?
- chollida1 14y agoClearly there are two things going on here that you seem to object to: 1) People actually find this link useful. 2) People don't want you to be the judge of what is appropriate on hacker news. Look there are always going to be links like this because people here like them. Whether it's book coupons or links to getting a free Chrome book from Google or free phones from Microsoft or Blackberry for developing apps, these links people find valuable. If it bothers you, then just skip it and move on.