3 ms·
"An interesting possibility, which I think should not be dismissed, is that a "true" fundamental theory exists, but that it may just be too hard for human brain
by tokenadult 18y ago
"An interesting possibility, which I think should not be dismissed, is that a "true" fundamental theory exists, but that it may just be too hard for human brains to grasp. A fish may be barely aware of the medium in which it lives and swims; certainly it has no intellectual powers to comprehend that water consists of interlinked atoms of hydrogen and oxygen. The microstructure of empty space could, likewise, be far too complex for unaided human brains to grasp."
That's a distinct possibility. Further mathematical research might still allow considerable refinement in describing what a correct fundamental theory does NOT imply.
- jbert 18y agoThat's the nice thing about the "shoulders of giants" though. By and large, scientific progress is cumulative. The cutting edge of quantum theory a few decades back is now undergraduate-level. Yes, there are probably theoretical limits to human understanding, but the analogy with fish breaks down because fish don't (as far as we know) have cultural accumulation of knowledge.
- nazgulnarsil 18y agoaccumulation of knowledge is different from a the possibility of a fundamental difference in the way reality works and the way our evolved brain works. see "wave/particle duality" for the simplest example of something that might be totally obvious to another type of intelligence.
- newt0311 18y agoI don't know... I am with Herbert here: "The universe is always one step beyond logic." We may (and in my opinion, definitely will) continue to refine theories of physics in the future but I don't think we will ever achieve perfection. There will always be some minuscule break that will give rise to a new theory. [UPDATE]: Of course, I have no logical means of proving that except inductive reasoning from history (we haven't come up with a perfect theory yet but we have continued to improve what we have) just as there is no deductive means to prove that a fundamental theory (however complex) does exist.
- gcheong 18y agoIt would be a cruel joke played upon us if we were to come to the end only to find out that we're the ones riding the cosmic short bus.