4 ms·
wealth == accumulated assets, but wealth != income High-income people are frequently wealthy (outside of incomes derived through lottery winnings), but the two
by prostoalex 14y ago
wealth == accumulated assets, but wealth != income
High-income people are frequently wealthy (outside of incomes derived through lottery winnings), but the two are not equal in their political views - those sitting on their wealth will be in favor of income taxes (since they barely have any), those who work for income will lean in favor of asset and consumption taxation (property, estate and sales taxes).
- notJim 14y agoThis seems like a riskily reductionist point, as we know that people aren't always single-issue voters focused on achieving their financial best interests.
- rhino42 14y agoBut categorically I would expect it to be a reasonable heuristic.
- prostoalex 14y agoOh, definitely. Even folks who are single-issue voters realize that outside of supermajority years executive branch of government has to compromise. However, the anecdotal evidence of "stored wealth vs current income" tax is there, notice how "let's-back-tax-everybodys-income" Prop-30-happy California is also home to "dont-you-dare-to-raise-taxes-on-my-mansions" Prop 13. My original remark was to point out that wealthy people and high income people are frequently advocating opposite causes.
- tsotha 14y ago>Prop-30-happy California is also home to "dont-you-dare-to-raise-taxes-on-my-mansions" Prop 13. Mansions? Hardly. More like "Don't raise taxes on my tiny tract home through the roof based on ridiculously inflated real estate values."
- prostoalex 14y agoIf you look at the places with highest volatility, it tends to be jobs-heavy SF Bay Area and LA. A farmer in Oxnard might see his farmhouse appreciate 10% here and there, East Palo Alto and Antioch (which I think you're describing) did not experience any significant swings even during the height of real estate bubble.
- tsotha 14y agoI was living in Southern California when prop 13 passed by an overwhelming margin. The people who benefited the most weren't wealthy at all. Instead, they were retired people on fixed incomes who were being forced by tax increases to move from houses in which they'd lived for three or four decades. Maybe in a state that didn't have both high sales taxes and high income taxes a cap on property taxes wouldn't make sense. But in California it does.