4 ms·
Yeah agriculture is bad for the environment, but at least it feeds us to keep us alive, so we can say it's worth it. Datacenters don't. They don't even create
by joe_mamba 5mo ago
Yeah agriculture is bad for the environment, but at least it feeds us to keep us alive, so we can say it's worth it. Datacenters don't.
They don't even create that many jobs like a factory for instance so we can say the mass employment offsets the environmental damage.
- deburo 5mo agoOne can say that food can be produced elsewhere, but also data centers might be a critical component of future society if we don't solve birth rates. Also, fewer births mean less food required.
- dukeyukey 5mo agoThe services provided by a data center do provide jobs. My job for one, and I'm guessing a majority of posters here too.
- darkwater 5mo ago[flagged]
- john_strinlai 5mo agothey said "that many jobs" not "no jobs". compared to something like a car factory, data centers do not provide that many jobs. (and the jobs are of significantly different nature)
- dukeyukey 5mo agoDirectly, sure. Indirectly, they have created many millions of jobs. Tens of millions at the very lowest. There are nearly 30 million web developers alone.
- john_strinlai 5mo agothe problem is that many of those jobs often aren't in the locale. by necessity, car factory workers work, live, spend money, and pay taxes in the same general area as the car factory. that does not hold true for web developers (which may be in entirely different countries).
- dukeyukey 5mo agoI recognise that makes it politically tricky, but "creates almost no jobs" and "creates lots of jobs, but dispersed elsewhere" are two very different statements. And for data centers the latter is true, and the former is a lie.
- LaSombra 5mo agoAs long as we don't see the damaged areas around data centers than all is fine, right? Where have I heard this before?
- jabl 5mo agoBut thanks to the magic of the Interwebs, most of those jobs don't have to be in the city, region, or even the same country as the one where the DC is located. So for a local politician, most of those jobs won't get them reelected.
- dukeyukey 5mo agoI realise it's a politically hard sell, but it's just a lie that data centers produce few jobs. Few direct jobs, sure, but the internet and cloud existing has created many, many millions of jobs.
- subscribed 5mo agoNormal datacentres, sure, but these services are already running from the existing datacentres. These purpose built DCs in the recent AI craze doesn't. A handful of security guys, handful of technicians and that's pretty much it
- niek_pas 5mo ago> Yeah agriculture is bad for the environment, but at least it feeds us to keep us alive This is true, but don't forget a _lot_ of agriculture feeds _animals_ that we in turn eat. If you want to make optimal use of land for human needs, most modern agriculture is not that.
- spiderfarmer 5mo agoThe problem is feed lots. There's no problem the more conventional practice of letting animals graze the majority of the year. If we didn't use those fields to feed and eat the animals, the grass would turn into CO2 and methane anyway. Or turn into boring forests. Not everything has to be optimal. That thinking leads to Thanos' snap. People generally enjoy meat. They also enjoy the landscape farmers created.
- markusw 5mo agoPlease at least pretend to read the article before posting something like that.
- jandrewrogers 5mo agoTens of millions of acres of agricultural land goes to things like production of corn ethanol. It is disingenuous to pretend we need this land to feed anybody. We have vastly more arable land than is needed to keep people from starving, even when used inefficiently to produce things like cattle feed.
- thinkindie 5mo agoMaybe in the US, but farmland is quite scarce in Lombardy.
- jandrewrogers 5mo agoJust because it is scarce doesn't mean it is productive. I have friends with farms and agricultural businesses in Italy. A lot of agricultural land is no longer cultivated by the families that own it because market prices are well below the cost of production in Italy.