Yes, attacker controlled size without limit is bad (and this is also true for heap allocations). For VLAs there is -Wvla-larger-than that can be used to ensure

Yes, attacker controlled size without limit is bad (and this is also true for heap allocations). For VLAs there is -Wvla-larger-than that can be used to ensure there is a hard limit. To understand the risks of VLAs one also has to compare it to the alternatives. A fixed-size array on the stack is basically always worse. alloca is substantially worse. heap allocation may be a bit better, but also much slower.