7 ms·
Why does any article focusing on women's experience have to have someone come along and say 'it's hard for us men'?
by vacri 14y ago
Why does any article focusing on women's experience have to have someone come along and say 'it's hard for us men'?
- mistercow 14y agoI sympathize with that point, but there's more to it than "what about teh menz?" The question is this: is this doing well on HN because HN is full of progressive-minded feminists upvoting a neat DIY project on its merits, or is it doing well on HN because it serves as fodder for the nerd-girl fantasies of a primarily male readership? I really think this is an important point that often gets missed on male dominated social news sites. Readers are quick to pat themselves on the back for the community's mature lack of slut-shaming, while neglecting to realize that an entirely different form of sexism and woman-objectification is taking place.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- mistercow 14y agoI don't think the majority explicitly thinks like that. Probably, if you asked them why they upvoted, their post hoc justification would be about how not-sexist they were. They'd be proud of it. But the post hoc justifications people come up with when they actually think about their motivations are very often not the original reasons for their actions, especially when the original reasons are not admirable. Don't get me wrong here - I don't think that men should feel guilty about their gut reactions to stories like this. If the "female nerds are popular on the internet because they fuel male nerd-girl fantasies" problem is one that needs to be addressed, I have no idea of how to address it. I just think we should recognize that that's what's happening instead of congratulating ourselves on being so modern.
- zerostar07 14y agoMy deleted comment was "I don't think the majority thinks like that" , which i deleted because i don't have data to back it up. But after reading your reply, what the hell dude/gal? Can't it be that people upvoted the article because sexy subject+technology is double win? Can't it be because i am actually jealous i haven't hacked my penis yet? And i'm not even a Feminist. Now your theory about guilt and nerdgirl fantasies... i think you 're really reaching there
- mistercow 14y ago>Can't it be that people upvoted the article because sexy subject+technology is double win? Can't it be because i am actually jealous i haven't hacked my penis yet? Yeah, it can be. I just doubt that it is. Sure, that may be the case for some people, but I'm talking about majority behavior, not universal behavior. >And i'm not even a feminist. That is apparent. >Now your theory about guilt and nerdgirl fantasies... i think you 're really reaching there Go to reddit and look at posts that fulfill the nerd-girl archetype. Now read the sleazy comments. We don't have those here, but that's because we have strong standards as a community for what is acceptable to say in comment threads, not because there aren't a lot of people here who would post those comments in the absence of those standards.
- franticpedantic 14y agoYou have absolutely zero evidence or basis for your assumption. The truth is that nobody has any idea what people's motivations were for upvoting it, but it deserved to be upvoted. The only person who has made this conversation sexist is you and those who brought the topic up.
- mistercow 14y agoI have plenty of evidence and basis in experience, and anyone can see exactly what I mean by following what I mentioned above. >The only person who has made this conversation sexist is you and those who brought the topic up. Ah yes, the same thing that anyone steeped in unchecked privilege says when they've got nothing left to argue. Black people are racist for complaining about discrimination, feminists are sexist for pointing out objectification, blah blah blah. Bored now.
- rizzom5000 14y agoNo need for stereotypes. The article deserves to be up voted because it is remarkably thorough and well written.
- mistercow 14y agoI agree that it deserves to be upvoted for those reasons. I just don't think that's necessarily the primary reason it has been upvoted. Examining the "would this be ranked this high if it were about penis hacking instead?" question is productive because it addresses that.
- rjknight 14y agoIt probably would be (assuming the ban on penis-related article titles could be circumvented). This is actually a seriously good article of the kind that frequently get upvoted and I don't think this case has much to do with gender.
- jQueryIsAwesome 14y agoIt has everything to do with gender, a man hacking a fleshlight would get none or almost none upvotes, I bet it would even get flagged by a few. Its a predictable fantasy of the average reader of HN, the equivalent of a photo of a pretty woman doing charity with a cat in reddit. Is not only the fact that she is a woman, is the surrounding context of a sexual stimulation device that provoque so many upvotes. Personally I would downvote this if I could, I don't like my tech articles biased by hormones.
- ErrantX 14y agoReading the threads on this page the comments appear genuinely interested in this tech, and related themes. Asking intelligent questions Etc. In fact, the only awkward thread, which seems a little sexist is this one... Food for thought.
- 14y ago
- stcredzero 14y ago> The question is this: is this doing well on HN because HN is full of progressive-minded feminists upvoting a neat DIY project on its merits, or is it doing well on HN because it serves as fodder for the nerd-girl fantasies of a primarily male readership? Yes. (With the caveat that "is full of" == "has more than 3")
- cdelsolar 14y agoSo we're sexist and objectifying women by upvoting the article?
- polto 14y agoAre you literally retarded or just trolling? If the former, go back to jebezel with the other sluts and never come back.
- Camillo 14y agoI don't think it's hard for men, frankly - I think it's a bit too easy for women. Our culture has really become too carefree about showing off sex toys - but only for women, it seems. Compare the mental image of a woman accidentally dropping a dildo or a vibrator out of her purse, and that of a man dropping a rubber vagina out of his bag. But there's a problem beyond the double standard. It's like public nudity: it sounds cool when you're a hormone-addled teenager, but then you realize that most people's bodies aren't a nice sight at all. That's why I'm thankful for common decency, and why I'm concerned about all the public dildo-waving: in most cases, I don't want to see your filthy body, and I certainly don't want to picture you having sex. Of course, I have no problem with this blog post - but the "openness" that's bothering some of these posters does have the potential to impinge on my rights of peaceful enjoyment of our public meatspace.
- mhurron 14y ago> Why does any article focusing on women's experience have to have someone come along and say 'it's hard for us men'? For the obvious joke? Immaturity can make the day so bright some times.
- pi18n 14y agoProbably because when women write about masturbatory experiences it's "awesome" and "liberated" and when men write about masturbatory experiences it's "gross" and "sad". So that commenter probably observed that double standard and questioned whether a, say, Fleshlight hacking article would be well-received or soundly mocked. But since women are universally disadvantaged in absolutely all aspects of life, it's simply rude to try and discuss the double standards biased against men. Because they are fictitious, of course.
- duaneb 14y agoI have no problem with articles on sex appearing on HN-I assume most of us are adults-but it's disappointing that there aren't similar topics for men. I'm not sure whether it's because male sexuality is narrower (yet, strangely, far more accepted if it's accepted at all) or because an article on female sexuality is more popular among the (presumably) male-dominated site. Anyway, this is the first article of it's kind I've ever seen on HN, so I'm not too worried. I haven't seen anything remotely approaching the misogyny that feels absolutely rampant on the rest of the internet (e.g. Reddit) that drove me here. In any case, more directly addressing your comment, I think it's a great question to ask- gender and sex differences in society are always interesting/potentially fruitful discussion topics, IMHO.
- tagada 14y agoThere aren't similar topics for men because men's sexuality is thought as being bestial, mechanical and obscene and vulgar, while women sexuality is thought as being sensual, soft, sweet and so on. Plus the nerd's world is full of men who are fascinated by women, and so they obviously are by women's topics. That's the reason why this article is that successful - even if the content and the descrition of the technical process is nice, there is nothing really incredible here, it's a soft easy reverse engineering and basic electronics hacking ... Nothing to justify the fist rank on HN during several days. There should be a study about that. "How a women's sexuality topic make the nerds thinking with their wand only".
- cindygallop 14y agoAbsolutely. You might find this piece from HuffPoUK on gender differences in marketing sex toys which I was interviewed for, interesting: http://www.huffingtonpost.co.uk/2012/11/20/sex-toys-sexist-relationships-language_n_2163982.html http://www.huffingtonpost.co.uk/2012/11/20/sex-toys-sexist-r...