3 ms·
>> I had thought (and Supreme Court ruled) you could not be compelled to unlock an encrypted device >Does that apply to non-citizens? If a CBP officer doesn't
by gruez 5mo ago
>> I had thought (and Supreme Court ruled) you could not be compelled to unlock an encrypted device
>Does that apply to non-citizens? If a CBP officer doesn't like you as a non-citizen, like your lack of cooperation during an interview, they could just deny your visa and your entry into the US.
That's exactly what "you could not be compelled to unlock an encrypted device" means? You won't get sent to the gulag for refusing to, but entry into the US was always conditional with very little room for recourse if the border agent doesn't like you.
- dylan604 5mo agoNot really sure what you're arguing, but it's not an answer to my question
- gruez 5mo agoYou don't "have to", but they can deport you and refuse entry in the future in retaliation. It's a variant of the TSA not being able to "compel" you to a search, but they can refuse you from flying.
- deleted 5mo ago[deleted]
- DANmode 5mo agoThey can lie, and pretend you’re uncooperative, or that their investigation took longer than the duration until your intended flight, but, no, they can’t legally refuse you from flying without cause or suspicion.
- two_handfuls 5mo agoThe question was: "Does that apply to non-citizens?" Saying "they can deport you" without specifying whether the hypothetical "you" is a citizen or not means you did not answer the question. Not that you have to answer a stranger's question, but I thought I would clear the confusion in the hope it may be helpful.
- gruez 5mo agoThe premise (non-citizen) is in the question and doesn't need to be repeated. C'mon, this isn't grade school where you have to answer questions by first restating the question in its entirety.
- dylan604 5mo agoNo, but even in grade school, the teacher would get the student to actually answer the question when it is clearly being evaded. Or maybe put the student's name on the board for wasting everyone's time for being obstinate.