6 ms·
Linux brings over €10 million savings for Munich
- m_for_monkey 14y agoThe first item on the list of related articles: Freiburg to switch back to MS Office (3 days ago) http://www.h-online.com/open/news/item/Freiburg-to-switch-back-to-MS-Office-1753898.html http://www.h-online.com/open/news/item/Freiburg-to-switch-ba...
- sounds 14y agoPersonally, I like the contrast: Freiburg will get to experience Windows 8 and update us on that, while Munich will update us on how much money they saved. That's what this article is about: how much money they saved.
- zdw 14y agoNote that they were using OpenOffice, not a more modern fork, and that they were running it in parallel with MS Office 2000, so using some form of Windows. They're in for a rude UI awakening when jumping to MS Office 2007 or later...
- dutchbrit 14y agoLibreOffice all the way :)
- Tsiolkovsky 14y agoYeah, that's a sad example of what vendor lock-in closed file formats cause and what bad migration planing does. I guess IT people in Freiburg could learn a lot from their fwllows in Munich.
- trimbo 14y agoI love Linux, and love Windows too (especially for games). It does make me happy to hear about Linux deployments like this. That said: Everyone who switches one way or the other claims savings. Their breakdown of savings raises questions. They have 15,000 machines and TFA says they'd be paying €280 a seat for Office upgrades and €173 a seat for Windows upgrades. I have worked for Windows companies with less seats, in the commercial space, that paid less. I also want to know what the workers think. I've tried OpenOffice but find the spreadsheet unusable compared to Excel. My low productivity in OpenOffice makes Office a bargain.
- mdda 14y agoPower Excel users use the keys (rather than the mouse). The new Office button bar forces you to loose all spacial understanding of where obscure menu items lie - fortunately, Microsoft retained key-compatibility with previous versions (even though those keystrokes no longer make any sense w.r.t. the visual interface). The debate that Microsoft has on cost per seat is dwarfed by retraining costs - which may actually be lower for LibreOffice than the transition onto the ButtonBar in Office 2010. Of course, Windows is going to move to Windows 8, and Linux desktops will be more familiar than ever... Personally, I've moved over to LibreOffice, writing a Python addin to get Bloomberg compatibility. My users are on LibreOffice for word-processing (practically no-one has noticed), for spreadsheets I'll let them flip back to Microsoft Excel if they have 'power user' problems/mindsets - but often find that they are taken aback by the button strip anyway.
- eisa01 14y agoI didnt't seriously start using Excel until the 2007 version, but I must say that the Ribbon is much better than the old system. The discoverability of keyboard shortcuts are much higher when you only have to press the alt key to reveal them. Of course I also use some other shortcuts that are not on the ribbon, but that's just a bonus.
- manifold 14y agoExcel 2010 is certainly more novice friendly, but I'd take 2003's interface back in a flash - customising/grouping shortcut icons doesn't seem nearly as friendly in 2010 and it's a big drawback. I also find it much quicker to scan lists of vertical text when looking for a menu item than to scan horiztonal lists of icons/text.
- antidoh 14y agoThey aren't shortcuts, they're replacements for mouse clicks, and you have to do the same number of key presses as mouse clicks. I don't have Windows open in front of me (still the holiday weekend). In Word, to paste text from the clipboard, unformatted, into the document by "pressing the alt key to reveal" the so-called shortcuts go something like this: - alt - H (I think, to further reveal or expose the Home "shortcuts") - V (to expose the paste functions) - S (because we want to paste Special) - U (unformatted) - and maybe U again to get the other flavor of Unformatted. That's five or six keystrokes, and that's not a shortcut. It feels like passive aggressiveness on Microsoft's part: "Oh, you don't like clicking? ... There, I fixed it."
- corporalagumbo 14y agoI wonder how the quality of their Linux systems compares to an equivalent Windows set-up. Do they have more crashes? Is it harder to train people to use Linux? More problems with program compatibility? Is Linux as easy to use, or are there inefficiencies? Saving money is one thing, but time = money so if using Linux wastes time then is it really an advantage? Maybe I'm just looking for problems. I'm a bit biased; I happen to think it's a matter of self-respect to spring for quality software instead of just always using the cheapest option. It's one reason why I would prefer to use MS Office over OpenOffice, because Office 2010 is a quality app with a polished interface whereas OpenOffice and its variants look to me pretty much like crap on a stick. I also like the idea of rewarding quality software and promoting more of its kind with your money. We should all be happy when smart people making good products get paychecks.
- kleiba 14y agoThese questions are worth asking. However, like you, I'm a bit biased too - except the opposite way. To me, some of the questions you raise (Do they have more crashes? [..] More problems with program compatibility?) are points I would traditionally associate with Windows rather than with Linux. Is it harder to train people to use Linux? is an interesting question. I think if people are already used to working with MS products staying with these products should provide an advantage it terms of training. However, I would expect a significant portion of the staff to use only a minimal feature set available in their setup, typically writing letters, etc. For them, I wouldn't expect the transition from MS Office to an open source office suite any harder than, say, the transition from traditional MS Office to the ribbon-based interface. Is Linux as easy to use, or are there inefficiencies? -- The whole "this year is the year of Linux on the desktop" joke will probably never get old, but I think everyone has to admit that Linux has come a long way in the last 15 years. For your average user, I would say there aren't any major differences between a Linux desktop and that of a commercial vendor, once the system has been set up. Of course, that still leaves the question whether Linux systems are set up as efficiently as Windows systems... I personally think that MS Office at least looks way more polished than any of the open source alternatives, and I would expect it to be a good deal ahead of the latters in application as well. But I can't say for sure because I've used Open-/LibreOffice exclusively for many years now. It's totally fine for whatever I want to do with it, and I would bet that it is absolutely sufficient for 90% of the use cases an average admin person has. So all in all MS products might still be a (good) notch ahead in terms of product quality, but I think that advantage is somewhat neglectable because Linux alternatives have certainly matured enough for the particular use case of a city administration.
- biot 14y agoI brought this up previously[0] in a discussion where Helsinki didn't go with LibreOffice as they found it would have been $21M Euros more expensive than staying with Microsoft. I'm reproducing my bullet points here as I think the claimed savings in this situation are actually false savings. They supposedly took training into consideration but I think they ignore loss of productivity inherent in the switch as well as compatibility issues. Consider the total costs of all the following: * How will incompatibilities be handled with their existing documents? Is LibreOffice absolutely 100% feature complete identical to Microsoft Office? If not, what proportion of documents use incompatible features? How much effort is required to determine this incompatibility? How much effort is required to redo these documents to fix the incompatibility? How many employees are required to be on such a conversion team and how long will the conversion take? Can the conversion even be done? * How is interaction done with external users who send Office documents? What happens when users outside their office send them Office documents which make use of incompatible features? Will this require maintaining an ongoing conversion team? What is the opportunity cost inherent in the delays in getting documents converted? * How is installation of LibreOffice done? Can it be setup on a centralized WSUS server and automatically deployed to every user as Microsoft Office can, or does it require an army of people manually installing it on thousands of PCs? How are updates for both version upgrades and security patches handled? What is the typical update schedule for LibreOffice (security-related patches, compatibility upgrades, etc.) and will this need to be done manually as well? How many man-hours per year will this take? * LibreOffice doesn't include an email product. What alternate solution would they use? What is the cost to convert all Outlook email and archives to this new solution? Can the new solution make use of all calendaring and other Exchange-related features that Outlook has? Can the new solution be deployed on WSUS and kept up to date automatically, or does this too require an army of people manually installing and doing updates? Can they maintain the security permissions they currently use, such as restricting the ability for users to forward internal communications outside the office? * LibreOffice doesn't have a Visio, Project, or OneNote replacements. What are they going to use for these? How do they convert existing documents and interact with external users who send them Office documents? Is it even possible? [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4235508 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4235508
- mtgx 14y ago
- Aardwolf 14y agoWow, does every city of that size that uses Windows pay that much to Microsoft?
- ams6110 14y agoThe hardware update savings struck me as a bit contrived. Maybe they didn't technically need to upgrade hardware in connection with OS upgrades, but hardware needs to be updated periodically regardless. Seems like they are just disassociating the timing and claiming savings.
- 3amOpsGuy 14y agoContrived is a bit uncharitable. 5 year old hardware (which would be around the calibre of a Core Duo with 1Gb ram?) is still perfectly serviceable for your average office worker. With Linux they have the choice to defer hw upgrade until it's justified for reasons other than 'we need to upgrade the OS and because the current hardware came with an OEM licence and so is not covered by any volume licencing deal that may be in place (without spending extra) its cheaper to buy a new PC with a Windows bundled than it is to just buy the software upgrade then the hardware when it's really needed'.
- ams6110 14y agoA city like Munich would, I would think, have a volume license arrangement and not rely on OEM licensing; they'd buy the hardware sans OS and provision their locally-configured OS image. I've never had issues with installing newer Windows versions on older hardware (within reason) in this scenario; though I don't use Windows as my primary OS I do have it around for when I need it.
- sounds 14y agoI'm not sure whether you were aware that almost every major Windows release has required significant new hardware purchases? Corporate IT usually delays rolling out each new Windows (preferable, but senior management gets impatient), but that just spreads the increased TCO over the hardware refresh cycle. 2006: Vista premium required new hardware because it required WDDM1.0, and the first cards to support it were the NVidia 8800's [1] [2] and ATI R520 core [3]. Note the whole "Vista capable" fiasco [1] [5], hence Vista premium is the relevant point. Windows 7 hardware requirements were the same as Windows Vista. 2012: Windows 8 requires at least 8 GB of RAM [4] even though Microsoft claims it has the same requirements as Vista (1 GB RAM). That also means the 32-bit version of 8 is crippled from the start. UEFI Secure Boot, also "not a requirement," will increase the hardware TCO for IT departments purchasing machines meant to have Windows 7 – they first have to disable Secure Boot. It's understandable that machines from 2006 will not still be around in 2012, but Microsoft is definitely the cause of the increased hardware TCO. [1] http://www.zdnet.com/blog/microsoft/vista-users-frustrations-with-nvidia-come-to-a-head/405 http://www.zdnet.com/blog/microsoft/vista-users-frustrations... [2] http://www.anandtech.com/show/2116 http://www.anandtech.com/show/2116 [3] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/R520 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/R520 [4] http://www.itwire.com/opinion-and-analysis/open-sauce/57536-installing-windows-8-without-secure-boot http://www.itwire.com/opinion-and-analysis/open-sauce/57536-... [5] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Criticism_of_Windows_Vista#Vista_capable_lawsuit http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Criticism_of_Windows_Vista#Vist...
- hk_kh 14y agoAs much as sometimes Stallman is harsh on some statements, I think this was spot on: "Little you value your freedom when you are not disposed to pay for it". I know this article talk about savings, even if it was costs would be of value.
- holri 14y agoBusiness economics vs. national economics a purely business economic point of view does not make sense in public spendind. No highway is econimical for itself. One must consider the national economic benefits. With free software, it is clearly higher than for proprietary. The license fees fund the stakeholders of an American monopoly. Expenditure on migration, training, adaptations benefits local companies and people, improves and promotes the local know-how and the common good free software.
- mseebach 14y agoNo, a million times no. This is the kind of thinking that makes the public sector a quagmire of inefficiency. The IT department of the city of Munich has exactly one mission and that is to enable the employees of the city to service the citizens of Munich in the most efficient manner - not playing politics on behalf of the free software movement (or Microsoft, for that matter). By the same yardstick, the city of Seattle should stick with Microsoft everything to protect local jobs, in spite of evidence of superior alternatives.
- holri 14y ago"The IT department of the city of Munich has exactly one mission and that is to enable the employees of the city to service the citizens of Munich in the most efficient manner" Exactly. It is more efficient for Munich as a City to support local business than to transfer money to american sharehoulders, if they think faresighted instead of shoresighted. Because part of the money comes back as taxes. National economy is not a profit business but a money circuit. Therefore the efficienty laws are different. The goal max. efficiency is the same, but the ways to accomplish this are totallly different, because the economic systems are different.
- mseebach 14y agoThe city shouldn't maximise for profit, that's clear. But in this case they might be optimizing for a vague political goal at the cost of quality of service. Stuff like, a planning permission taking longer to process, but, hey, we benefited the local open source community. I'm not saying that's what happened, I'm saying that's the kind of unintended consequences you risk running into when you muddle the mission goal. By the way, any contract of any meaningful size must be tendered EU-wide. It's illegal for a city to demand that its providers are local.
- frozenport 14y agoI spent the summer working with a lot of old time programmers who were in the field since the early 70s. To me Linux was a privilege to them it was stingy: they wanted PowerPoint, Outlook and did their work in Putty.
- ommunist 14y agoPlease do promote this, dudes! The more local governments will use Linux, the better users you shall have for your software or services!
- perlgeek 14y agoI was present in a hearing by the Bundestag (German Parliament) of the director of LiMux project. I particularly remember two of his points: The main goal of the project was to reduce vendor lock-in, not financial savings. It is unacceptable for a governmental entity to be so dependent on a single corporation (especially if the majority of that company doesn't fall under the countrie's control). The main problem of the migration was that so many third parties insist on exchanging data through office documents (even though they are often ill suited for that), instead of providing an API or a simple data file format. (for those of you who can speak German, here is the protocol: http://www.bundestag.de/internetenquete/dokumentation/Interoperabilitaet_Standards_Freie_Software/PGISF_2012-09-21/PGISF_2012-09-21_Expertengespraech_Interoperabilitaet_Protokoll.pdf http://www.bundestag.de/internetenquete/dokumentation/Intero... )
- nrnjsir 14y agoCompanies and public services who use commercial closed software usually pays someone for creating it - will they now send money upstreams to the different software projects that makes it possible? GNU, Linux foundation, Document Foundation, GNOME, KDE and Mozilla?