3 ms·
> This article isn't very good. Mother Jones is an overtly political operation, so you're unlikely to read reporting that's not trying to Make A Point. Compar
by davidw 14y ago
> This article isn't very good.
Mother Jones is an overtly political operation, so you're unlikely to read reporting that's not trying to Make A Point. Compare to Reason.com or Mises.org or similar outlets whose positions are extremely predictable.
That's not to say things are necessarily wrong, but I tend to take what they have to say with a large grain of salt, and am not all that enthusiastic about seeing them on this site, as they tend to be sort of the opposite of 'intellectually curious' and more along the lines of "See! Big companies are EEEEEVIIIIL!" or on the other side "Look! Free markets are always the best possible thing, in every situation!"
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mother_Jones_%28magazine%29 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mother_Jones_%28magazine%29
- _delirium 14y agoI tend not to like the headlines and slant of either Mother Jones or Reason for similar reasons, but I do think a lot of interesting stuff shows up in both of them, so I've shied away from completely ignoring them (this article isn't really one of the better examples of that point, though). With some articles, I can mentally imagine rewriting them with slightly less inflammatory language, and fewer digressions and cheap shots, and end up with something quite good. One hypothesis for why good content might show up in such venues that isn't redundant with articles from a more neutral source (which I would prefer, all else being equal) is they basically get a bit of "partisan bonus" income (built-in readership and appeal to a base) which lets them fund some actual, not-purely-propaganda investigative journalism which would be harder to fund if they didn't position themselves in that manner. Put differently, it can sometimes be a way of monetizing journalism that wouldn't otherwise be linkbaity enough to be profitable, by slathering the core of what might've been a good article in a layer of partisan appeal to get eyeballs. Of course, that explanation does rely on there being such a core...
- teeja 14y ago<i>reporting that's not trying to Make A Point.</i> As opposed to, say, some comments in HN?